Intensive research efforts have been undertaken to slow human aging and therefore potentially delay the onset of age-related diseases. These efforts have generated an enormous amount of high-throughput data covering different levels in the physiologic hierarchy, e.g., genetic, epigenetic, transcriptomic, proteomic, and metabolomic, etc. We gathered 15 independent sources of information about genes potentially involved in human longevity and lifespan (N = 5836) and subjected them to various integrated analyses. Many of these genes were initially identified in non-human species, and we investigated their orthologs in three non-human species [i.e., mice (N = 967), fruit fly (N = 449), and worm (N = 411)] for further analysis. We characterized experimentally determined protein-protein interaction networks (PPIN) involving each species’ genes from 9 known protein databases and studied the enriched biological pathways among the individually constructed PPINs. We observed three important signaling pathways: FoxO signaling, mTOR signaling, and autophagy to be common and highly enriched in all four species (p-value ≤ 0.001). Our study implies that the interaction of proteins involved in the mechanistic target of rapamycin (mTOR) signaling pathway is somewhat limited to each species or that a “rewiring” of specific networks has taken place over time. To corroborate our findings, we repeated our analysis in 43 different human tissues. We investigated conserved modules in various tissue-specific PPINs of the longevity-associated genes based upon their protein expression. This analysis also revealed mTOR signaling as shared biological processes across four different human tissue-specific PPINs for liver, heart, skeletal muscle, and adipose tissue. Further, we explored our results’ translational potential by assessing the protein interactions with all the reported drugs and compounds that have been experimentally verified to promote longevity in the three-comparator species. We observed that the target proteins of the FDA-approved drug rapamycin (a known inhibitor of mTOR) were conserved across all four species. Drugs like melatonin and metformin exhibited shared targets with rapamycin in the human PPIN. The detailed information about the curated gene list, cross-species orthologs, PPIN, and pathways was assembled in an interactive data visualization portal using RStudio’s Shiny framework (https://agingnetwork.shinyapps.io/frontiers/).