“…According to claims, GDP has a negative coefficient and has both short- and long-term effects on CO2 emissions ; this implies that if GDP rises by 1%, CO2 emissions decrease by 0.779 percent and 1.720 percent, respectively. This result is similar to Amarante et al (2021) , Al-mulali et al (2016) , Ahmed (2020) , Akif and Asumadu (2019) , Prince and Okechukwu (2019) , Liu et al (2020) , Voumik et al (2022b) and Vo and Vo (2019) and the result is contradicted to Ozgur et al (2022) , Safi et al (2021) , Tao et al (2021) , Acaravci and Ozturk (2010) , Ahmed et al (2020) , Aydin et al (2019) , Awais and Wang (2019) , Abbasi et al (2020) , Bano et al (2018) , Tauseef et al (2019) , Erdogan et al (2020) , Fakher (2019) , Marrero (2010) , and Liu et al (2020) . By contrast, the coefficient of is positive and significant statistically, which shows that if rises by 1 percent, then it increases emissions by 0.0124 percent.…”