The Scapegoat Mechanism in Human Evolution: An Analysis of René Girard’s Hypothesis on the Process of Hominization

Abstract

According to anthropological philosopher René Girard (1923–2015), an important human adaptation is our propensity to victimize or scapegoat. He argued that other traits upon which human sociality depends would have destabilized primate dominance-based social hierarchies, making conspecific conflict a limiting factor in hominin evolution. He surmised that a novel mechanism for inhibiting intragroup conflict must have emerged contemporaneously with our social traits, and speculated that this was the tendency to spontaneously unite around the victimization of single individuals. He described an unconscious tendency to both ascribe blame and to imbue the accused with a sacred mystique. This emotionally cathartic scapegoat mechanism, he claimed, enhanced social cohesion, and was the origin of religion, mythology, sacrifice, ritual, cultural institutions, and social norms. It would have functioned by modifying the beliefs and behaviors of the group, rather than of the accused, making the act of accusation more important than the substance. This article aims to examine the empirical evidence for Girard’s claims, and argues that the scapegoat hypothesis has commonalities with several other evolutionary hypotheses, including Wrangham’s execution hypothesis on self-domestication, Dunbar’s hypothesis on the role of storytelling in maintaining group stability, and DeScioli and Kurzban’s hypothesis on the role of non-consequentialist morality in curtailing conflict. Potential implications of the scapegoat hypothesis for evolutionary psychology and psychiatry are discussed.

Perjalanan-Singgah Guru Pendidikan Kristen dan Kerja-kerja disiplin di Kelas IPS Kota Palangka Raya

“…Pendidikan moral, etika, mental, spiritual, dan perilaku positif ditumbuhkan guna membentuk kepribadian siswa, dan para guru serta siswa terlibat secara interaktif dalam proses pendidikan (Apandie & Rahmelia, 2020Fiddler, 2017;Lu & Lu, 2010;Munte, 2022a;Pohl, 2011;Riordan, 2021;Teriasi et al, 2022;van Wynen & Niemandt, 2020;Wainarisi & Tumbol, 2022a;Wersig & Wilson-Smith, 2021). Pendidikan menjadi hal yang penting dalam kehidupan manusia sehingga pada proses belajar mengajar ditekankan untuk dapat fokus pada pembentukan kepribadian peserta didik.…”

Spotting Rooms for the Dignity of Jomblo in Higher Education

“…The term singles is quite often used by Indonesian people. Although not a standardized word, the term singles is often found both in direct conversation and in cyberspace (Apandie & Rahmelia, 2020Apandie, Rahmelia, Risvan, & Kodun, 2022;Casey, Novick, & Lourenco, 2021;Khanolainen et al, 2023;Morgan, 2023;Riordan, 2021). This term comes from the word jomlo which means old girl which then changes its meaning to jomblo which means someone who does not have a partner.…”

The evolution of peace

“…This, he suggested, was one of the main causes of early hominin conflict, or intragroup conflict at least. His scapegoat hypothesis (Girard, 1986;Riordan, 2021) posits that such conflict would have been countered by a phenomenon which would itself have been an emergent property of imitation, that is, a tendency to respond to crises, including conflict-related crises, by imitating the blaming of an often arbitrarily selected victim, culminating in their expulsion, or more likely, their killing by mob violence. He suggested that such spontaneous, violent and cathartic events had strong unifying, and thus coordinating effects on communities, and were the origin of mythological, religious, and by extension moral, narratives, as archaic communities may have, post hoc, misidentified the victim as God-like, perceiving them to have both caused and resolved the crisis.…”