Many feeding kinematic studies do not identify sources of mechanical variation related to the type or size of prey. Studies of salamanders have concentrated on determining the morphological basis of feeding mechanics or on phylogenetic comparisons; few have examined variability within a species. A series of feeding trials was designed to test whether PZethodon cinereus of different agelsize classes exhibits stereotypic patterns in capturing prey of differing type and size. Stopframe video analyses of feedings were made using 19 salamanders of varying body size and four prey types chosen to resemble items in the natural diet of the species. Five morphological features of each salamander, length and width of prey items, and 15 kinematic variables were used to describe each feeding trial.Statistical analyses of kinematic and morphological variables show that the feeding behavior of this species varies significantly with prey type. Effects of salamander size and prey size within prey types were a source of variation in some kinematic variables; among-individual variation partitioned with salamander body size. Different feeding modes resulted from distinctive combinations of distances from prey, amount of tongue protrusion, body movements, and duration of mouth closure, which varied with the use of jaw prehension and lingual prey capture. Presence of a repertoire of behaviors, composed of versatile combinations of movements, suggests that Plethodon cinereus modulates feeding mechanics to capture different types of prey. Consideration of natural prey in experiments, and of prey type in comparisons made across taxa, are necessary to investigations of the evolution of feeding behaviors.