We find that oil price rises from a strengthening global economy have a statedependent lead on US equity market beliefs and preferences. When equity volatility is low, rising oil prices lead higher cashflow expectations, lower longrun (LR) volatility, and increased LR risk aversion. When volatility is high, markets focus on the contractionary effects of higher input costs, with rising oil prices leading decreased cashflow expectations, higher LR volatility, and decreased LR risk aversion. Findings suggest important refinements for asset pricing, portfolio choice, and models that link financial markets to the macroeconomy.