“…In an effort to build upon their successes and help them develop, the notion of a summative tool was replaced with other formative tools. In our universitybased Professional Development School (PDS) work (Damore, Kapustka, & McDevitt, 2011;Kapustka & Damore, 2012;Damore & Kapustka, 2007), we, the university faculty and PDS school liaisons, questioned the validity of the use of a traditional, college of education prescribed, checklist-based performance assessment as an effective evaluation of student teachers. Concerns focused specifically on the structure and content of the supervisory feedback conference and perceived limitations for yielding improvement in the student teacher's growth and development.…”