The use of reflective diaries in end of life training programmes: a study exploring the impact of self-reflection on the participants in a volunteer training programme

Abstract

BackgroundA training programme was developed and delivered to a cohort of volunteers who were preparing for a unique role to provide companionship to dying patients in the acute hospital setting. This comprehensive programme aimed to provide an opportunity for participants to fully understand the nature and responsibilities of the role, whilst also allowing sufficient time to assess the qualities and competencies of participants for their ongoing volunteering role.Participants completed reflective diaries throughout the training course to record their ongoing thoughts and feelings. The purpose of this paper is to present a phenomenological analysis of these entries to understand participants’ experiences, perceptions and motivations.MethodThe wider study was structured into three phases. Phase 1 was the delivery of a 12 week, bespoke training programme; Phase 2 involved a 26 week pilot implementation of the Care of the Dying Volunteer Service and Phase 3 was the research evaluation of the training and implementation which would inform the further development of the training programme.Self-reflection is a common component of End of Life training programmes and volunteers in this study completed a reflective diary after participation in each of the training sessions. A thematic analysis was undertaken to explore and understand the participants’ experience, perceptions and motivations in relation to their participation in the training.ResultsAll 19 volunteers completed the reflective diaries. From a potential 228 diary entries over the 12 week training programme, 178 diary entries were submitted (78 %). The following key themes were identified: Dying Alone and the importance of being present, Personal loss and the reconstruction of meaning, Self-Awareness and Personal growth, Self-preservation and Coping strategies and group unity/cohesion.ConclusionsThe participants in this study demonstrated that they were able to use the diaries as an appropriate medium for reflection. Their reflections were also instrumental in the ongoing revision and development of the training programme. Analysis of their entries illustrated that the diaries could provide the opportunity for a reappraisal of their world view and personal philosophy around death and dying. Further research is undoubtedly required, however this paper suggests that self-reflection in this way, supports preparation in honing the appropriate attitudes and qualities required to work in this role.

Using a Reflective Diary Method to Investigate the Experiences of Paid Home Care Workers Caring for People With Dementia

“…Reflective diaries have long been advocated as a method to bridge the gap between theory and practice in other occupational groups with high levels of interpersonal demands, including nurses and teachers. [49][50][51] This study has shown that home care workers are not only happy to keep reflective diaries but also that in doing so they derive benefits, both personal and professional, while contributing to a fuller understanding of the essential ingredients of good home care. By implication, this might be true for other occupational groups who are also relatively voiceless, or whose work is done out of sight.…”

The value of poetry therapy for people in palliative and end of life care

“…Practicing self-reflection in end of life can enable people to identify their feelings (30).. and consider the influence of these on their practice (33). Self-awareness is necessary for the personal and professional development of nurses (34,35) Lack of knowledge and confidence can inhibit nurse's ability to have an active role in supporting people in palliative care, and healthcare professionals can experience challenges with initiating conversations relating to death (36,37).…”

‘End of life could be on any ward really’: A qualitative study of hospital volunteers’ end-of-life care training needs and learning preferences

“…57 More recently, novel initiatives have involved training volunteers in hospitals for specific roles related to palliative and EoLC. For example, in the United States, Sanon et al 58 trained hospital volunteers to support older people admitted to emergency departments, while in the United Kingdom, Germain et al 59 trained volunteers for a Care of the Dying Volunteer Service (designed for wards with high numbers of deaths and palliative care referrals). However, our study findings highlight that hospital volunteers in general support roles also encounter many challenges related to EoLC.…”