The validity of Iran’s national university entrance examination (Konkoor) for predicting medical students’ academic performance

Abstract

Background In Iran, admission to medical school is based solely on the results of the highly competitive, nationwide Konkoor examination. This paper examines the predictive validity of Konkoor scores, alone and in combination with high school grade point averages (hsGPAs), for the academic performance of public medical school students in Iran. Methods This study followed the cohort of 2003 matriculants at public medical schools in Iran from entrance through internship. The predictor variables were Konkoor total and subsection scores and hsGPAs. The outcome variables were (1) Comprehensive Basic Sciences Exam (CBSE) scores; (2) Comprehensive Pre-Internship Exam (CPIE) scores; and (3) medical school grade point averages (msGPAs) for the courses taken before internship. Pearson correlation and regression analyses were used to assess the relationships between the selection criteria and academic performance. Results There were 2126 matriculants (1374 women and 752 men) in 2003. Among the outcome variables, the CBSE had the strongest association with the Konkoor total score ( r = 0.473), followed by msGPA ( r = 0.339) and the CPIE ( r = 0.326). While adding hsGPAs to the Konkoor total score almost doubled the power to predict msGPAs ( R 2 = 0.225), it did not have a substantial effect on CBSE or CPIE prediction. Conclusions The Konkoor alone, and even in combination with hsGPA, is a relatively poor predictor of medical students’ academic performance, and its predictive validity declines over the academic years of medical school. Care should be taken to develop comprehensive admissions criteria, covering both cognitive and non-cognitive factors, to identify the best applicants to become "good doctors" in the future. The findings of this study can be helpful for policy makers in the medical education field.

Evaluation of Educational Environment for Medical Students of a Tertiary Pediatric Hospital in Tehran, Using DREEM Questionnaire

“…In the Iranian medical schools, knowledge of students is best determined by cumulative grade point average (cGPA), medical students’ comprehensive basic sciences exam (CBSE) score, and national university entrance exam (known as Konkoor) rank (19). …”

Participating in university entrance exam despite repeated failure: a qualitative study of participants’ experiences

“…Studies show that an optimum combination of these factors should be considered to select medical students for medical universities, and being on the extreme side of high intellectual ability is not enough to select a candidate for medical education 64 . On the other hand, performance on the entrance exam is a relatively poor predictor of future academic performance, and that its predictive validity declines over the academic years of medical school 65 . So, it can be hypothesized that the two following approaches might be useful to manage the condition.…”

Response to ‘An uninformed methodology’

“…Those who assessed the questionnaires were faculty members of the Educational Development Center of Tehran University of Medical Sciences who had formal education in this field. ''Having prior medical experience'' for medical students is not usual in Iran, because the only criterion for medicine is the university entrance exam which is just an academic score (Farrokhi-Khajeh-Pasha et al 2012). Because of its highly competitive nature, the students are not required to have any other activity.…”