The violent gang and the construction of masculinity amongst socially excluded young men

Abstract

PurposeThe aim of this paper is to help in understanding the relationship between the construction of the male identity and how social violence may be “reproduced” (using the concept of habitus after Pierre Bourdieu), in poor and socially excluded contexts. The paper aims to inform debate and policy making.Design/methodology/approachThe paper draws on empirical data collected in 2008, in the form of life‐history interviews with male youths – including members and non‐members of gangs – from two poor and very violent neighbourhoods in Medellín, Colombia's second largest city.FindingsMasculinities alone do not account for urban violence, but they play an integral role why violence is reproduced. In socio‐economically excluded contexts the gang becomes an attractive vehicle for “doing masculinity” for boys and young men. Youths who did not join gangs tended to have family support to develop a “moral rejection” of gangs, crime and violence during childhood, which contributed to them finding non‐gang pathways to manhood. Youths who joined gangs were less likely to develop this “moral rejection” during childhood, often due to family problems; and were more likely to admire older gang members, and perceive the gang as an attractive pathway to manhood.Research limitations/implicationsAs the sole researcher a limited number of 32 individuals were interviewed.Originality/valueThere is a lack of research on masculinities and gang affiliation in the UK and across the globe. This paper provides new conceptual ideas for understanding why young men make up the vast majority of violent gang members, whilst providing an original data set from a very violent urban setting.

Voices of Quiet Desistance in UK Prisons: Exploring Emergence of New Identities Under Desistance Constraint

“…Violent confrontations between former street gang rivals – combined with the competition for recognised status that arose from drug procurement and distribution within the prisons – meant that our interviewees were hindered in their attempts fully to reform. As Baird () argues, male gang members may occupy a significant ontological position in the field of masculinity, symbolised through the accumulation and display of power, respect, and money. Where monological expressions of masculinity are repeatedly given value by young men, violence may become entrenched and normalised (Carrington, McIntosh and Scott ).…”

Gap Analysis Report: Citizen Security in Belize

“…The single major report on youth violence in Belize (the Gayle Report) identifies masculinity, in combination with the contradictory pressures of notions of manhood in settings of socioeconomic marginalization, as a major factor in gang dynamics in Belize. Research on urban youth gangs in other areas of Latin America and the Caribbean reinforces this concept: machismo alone does not generate gang violence, but certain versions of violent masculinity, once established, can exacerbate the social role and power of gangs (Baird, 2012). For change to occur, youth must develop not only alternative interests and values, but must also talk about and alter their conceptions of masculinity and femininity.…”

Dimensions of Gang Issues at the National and International Level

“…Organized crime is defined as a systematic and planned crime committed by hierarchically structured group of persons, among whom there is a distribution of functions (Novotný et al, 2008). Baird (2012) conducted the research among gang members (in the UK), and concluded that masculinity plays a vital role in the cohesion and strength of the gang and a prerequisite for the effectiveness of organized crime. The contemporary trends of organised crime show the changing scale and nature of gang networks.'…”