The Wicked Character of Sustainable Supply Chain Management: Evidence from Sustainability Reports

Abstract

Supply chains are changing their business paradigm as they strive for sustainability and not just for increasing profits. Sustainability, however, is a concept that is open to interpretation since it is based on societal and organizational values. Little is known about what companies actually mean when referring to sustainability, and how this contrasts with the understanding at different echelons of the supply chain. Diverging interpretations and translations of sustainability among stakeholders, termed wicked problems, affect the progress of sustainable supply chain management. This paper aims to contribute to closing the gap between our common sense expectations and the actual evidence from sustainability reports of how sustainability evolves from abstract ideas to operational practices across the supply chain. To this end, this study employs a computer‐aided content analysis of 142 corporate sustainability reports across 12 industries. Building on the findings, and using the lens of wicked problems, this paper provides guidance to practitioners on how to develop strategies that are effective across the whole supply chain. Copyright © 2015 John Wiley & Sons, Ltd and ERP Environment

The Production of Food and Fiber: An Adaptation of CoP Features for Sustainable Water Use in Agribusiness

“…The domain of CoP is presented in the common ground of economic and ethical interests as well as responsibilities. It underscores the importance of setting a strategic direction [56], creating a shared vision [57], articulating a strategic intent of the relationship [58], and setting goals to integrate financial and environmental measurements [59]. Therefore, we searched for evidence of strategic objectives that are set and ratified by its top management and recognized through governance committees.…”

Evaluation and Selection of Sustainable Strategy for Green Supply Chain Management Implementation

“…According to this perspective sustainability can be achieved at the intersection of all three dimensions (Parrish, ). Thus, organizations should endeavour to perform well on all three dimensions of the TBL (Meckenstock et al ., ). Sustainability is integrally uncertain and open to interpretation (Lazarus, ).…”

“…However, there is little consent about sustainability in SCs among the managers (Giunipero et al ., ). Therefore, sharing information on sustainability issues will lead to a more sustainable SC within the organization (Meckenstock et al ., ).…”

Quantitative indicators for social sustainability assessment of society and product responsibility aspects in supply chains

“…Further, the coding schemes were tested in several sustainability reports and further revised until receiving satisfactory results. Issues related to reliability were eliminated by creating coding rules while doing machine coding (Meckenstock et al, 2015). This ensured stability and reproducibility of results (Krippendroff, 2004).…”

“…What can also be observed from Figure 3 is that the keyword occurrence for CO2 emission is highest for midstream echelon. That can be explained by the fact that midstream echelon involve production and assembly (Meckenstock et al, 2015), what is one of the main sources of CO2 emission (Martínez & Fransoo, 2017). Further, it can be observed that corruption is of high concern, where percentage of keyword occurrence decreases by moving from upstream to downstream echelon.…”