“…Previous review articles of academic research articles in tourism and hospitality can be divided into several types: retrospective analyses of one or more particular journals especially, Annals of Tourism Research (Long, 1998;Swain, Brent, & Long, 1998;Tribe & Xiao, 2011;Xiao, Jafari, Cloke, & Tribe, 2013;Xiao & Smith, 2006), Tourism Management (Ryan, 2009), and these two journals (Benckendorff, 2009;Page, 2003); several journals within a certain period of time (Ballantyne, Packer, & Axelsen, 2009;Cheng, Li, Petrick, & O'Leary, 2011;Severt, Tesone, Bottorff, & Carpenter, 2009;Svensson, Svaeri, & Einarsen, 2009a); and analyses of specific fields (e.g. hospitality or tourism), as well as comparisons between research on tourism and hospitality (Baloglu & Assante, 1999;Hall, 2011;Hung & Law, 2011;Kim, Savage, Howey, & Van Hoof, 2009;McKercher, 2012;Park, Phillips, Canter, & Abbott, 2011).…”