“…In [10], a DC bias-less, filter-less frequency octo-tupler circuit is proposed, whose performance is not limited by carefully adjusting modulation index, rather it can operate for a wide range of modulation index. In this context, the proposed circuit herein is not superior, as the multiplication depends upon adjusting the modulation index to m 2.4 or 5.37 ≤ m ≤ 5.48, but it is advantageous when one takes into account that in addition to frequency multiplication, it can perform SSB modulation and the proposed circuit needs only four-PM, which is half the number of PM used in [10]. Although the unused ports of the four MZM in [10] can be combined with another 4 × 4 MMI to obtain the operation of SSB, unlike the circuit proposed herein, it requires the applied RF carrier phases to be changed from 0°, 45°, 90°, and 135°to 0°, 90°, 90°, and 0°and an undesirable waveguide crossover is introduced.…”