Theoretical basis for sampling statistics useful for detecting and isolating rare cells using flow cytometry and cell sorting

Abstract

This paper describes new approaches to calculating the number of cells that need to be processed using flow cytometry (FCM) techniques and the subsequent time required in order to isolate a specific number of cells having selected characteristics. The methods proposed use probabilistic assumptions about the contents of the sample to be sorted, logarithmic/exponential transformations to avert the computer “underflow” and “overflow” limitations of brute force calculations for the parameters of the binomial distribution imposed by existing computer hardware, and an established mathematical procedure for calculating error bounds for the normal approximation to the binomial distribution. Estimates are derived for the total number of cells in the FCM sample volume that must be available for processing and, for given FCM cell sorting decision speeds, the total elapsed times necessary to conduct particular experiments. The proposed approach obviates the need to resort to calculation expediencies such as the theoretically limited Poisson approximation for what can be considered a Bernoulli process mathematically characterized by the binomial distribution. Tables and graphs illustrate the projected times required to complete FCM experiments as a function of “effective” cell sorting decision speeds. Results from this paper also demonstrate that, as the “effective” cell sorting decision speed increases, there may not be a corresponding linear decrease in the time required to sort a given number of cells with selected statistical properties. The focus of this paper is on the use of innovative mathematical techniques for the design of experiments involving rare cell sorting. However, these same computational approaches may also prove useful for the high‐speed enrichment sorting of non‐rare cell subpopulations. Cytometry 27:233–238, 1997. © 1997 Wiley‐Liss, Inc.

Direct enumeration and functional assessment of circulating dendritic cells in patients with liver disease†

“…We gated our collection on 10,000 lineage-negative/dim events, increasing the total number of events collected to an average of approximately 150,000 events, instead of the manufacturer's recommended 50,000. This assured statistical significance at the 100-cell/specimen level because counting 150,000 events would give accuracy to 1 cell per 1500 at the 95% confidence level, 22 maintaining consistency between specimens.…”

High-throughput single-microparticle imaging flow analyzer

“…While statistically insignificant and hence often ignored, rare events among a large heterogeneous population of cells in blood such as hematopoietic stem cells (39), antigen-specific Tcells (40), and circulating tumor cells (41,42) (Table S4) are important in biomedical research as well as medical diagnostics and therapeutics (43). Such rare cells can be identified by a combination of morphological (i.e., size, circularity, and clustering) and biochemical (i.e., surface antigens) markers.…”

Statistical considerations for enumeration of circulating tumor cells

“…In model systems, rare event detection is often referred to as the ability to detect a single cell of a specific composition in a background of a certain number of other cells (1)(2)(3). However, in clinical applications utilizing rare event detection, the actual issues are the ability to detect the cells of interest in a limited volume and the ability to discern these cells from other cells, particularly from cell debris and other garbage (4,5).…”