“…Appearance of Ti 2p3/2 at 458.3 eV confirmed that Ti remains in the 4+ oxidation state within our CCTO crystals [27]. The V 2p3/2 in the 4+ oxidation state appeared at 516.2 eV [28], 516.3 eV [29], 515.7 eV [30] and 515.95 eV [31] where the same peak located at 517.11 eV [32,33], 516.95 eV [28] and 516.7 eV [34] when its oxidation state is 5+. For our CCTO sample, V 2p3/2 peak position was located in the energy range corresponding to 4+ oxidation state, thus we may conclude that V substituted Ti which remains in the 4+ oxidation state.…”