Three-stage publishing to support evidence-based management practice

Abstract

This article proposes a 4-step model for scientific dissemination that aims to promote evidence-based professional practice in Operations Management or Human Resource Management as well as research with a more transparent and reproducible process. These 4 steps include:1 social network announcements,2 dissemination to scientific journals, 3 dissemination to social networks, and 4 scientific dissemination to professional journals. Central to the 4-step model is a three-stage publication process within the second step, which adds an additional stage to the two previously proposed (Marin-Garcia, 2015). These three publication stages begin with a protocol paper, are followed by a data paper, and finish with a traditional article. Each stage promotes research with merit which is citable and recognizable as such before the scientific evaluation bodies. As two of these stages are largely unknown within the fields of Business and Management, I define the details of a protocol paper and a data paper including their contents. In addition, I provide examples of both papers as well as the other steps of the science dissemination model. This model can be adopted by researchers as a means of achieving greater impact and transfer of research results. This work intends to help researchers to understand, to evaluate, and to make better decisions about how their research reaches society at large outside of academia.In this way, WPOM aligns with the recommendations of several leading journals in the field of business management on the need to promote transparent, accessible, and replicable science (Beugelsdijk et al., 2020). WPOM goes one step further in compliance with this direction by having relevant journals that not only accept, but also actively encourage the publication of protocol papers and data papers. WPOM strives to pioneer in this field of Business and Management.This article also explores the potential prevalence of protocol papers and data papers within the set of all articles published in journals indexed in Clarivate Web of Science and Scopus.With this editorial, WPOM is committed to promoting this model by accepting for review any of the three types of scientific contributions including protocol papers, data papers, and traditional papers.

Supply chain agility and performance: evidence from a meta-analysis

“…The literature search has been developed using an SLR protocol, which is widely accepted in a variety of scientific fields including SC management, in general (Marin-Garcia et al, 2018a, b;Sanchez-Ruiz et al, 2020;Marin-Garcia, 2021) and SCA, in particular (e.g. Al Humdan et al, 2020;Gligor et al, 2019;Li et al, 2008;Sharma et al, 2020).…”

“…, 2018a, b; Sanchez-Ruiz et al. , 2020; Marin-Garcia, 2021) and SCA, in particular (e.g. Al Humdan et al.…”

Case report papers guidelines: Recommendations for the reporting of case studies or action research in Business Management

“…(Bonache, 1999;McCutcheon & Meredith, 1993;Voss et al, 2002). All this must be performed while maintaining methodological rigour to mitigate against a lack of transparency, and to assure validity and reliability in the measurements processed (Marin-Garcia, 2015;Marin-Garcia, 2021;Tight, 2017;Voss et al, 2002).…”