Tools for measuring gender equality and women’s empowerment (GEWE) indicators in humanitarian settings

Abstract

Background Effective measurement of Gender Equality and Women’s Empowerment (GEWE) is challenging in low and middle-income countries (LMICs), and even more so in humanitarian settings. Conflict, natural disasters, and epidemics may increase gender inequities, but also present an opportunity to address them. This scoping review describes and identifies gaps in the measurement tools, methods, and indicators used to measure GEWE in humanitarian settings, and presents a dashboard that can be used by researchers, organizations and governments to identify GEWE measurement tools. Methods Scientific articles published between January 2004 and November 2019 were identified using Embase, Medline, PsycInfo, CINAHL, Scopus, and PAIS index. Relevant non peer-reviewed literature was downloaded from the websites of humanitarian organizations. Publications on women and/or girls impacted by a humanitarian crisis in a LMIC, within 5 years of data collection, were included. Publications were double-screened in the title/abstract and full-text stages. We used a machine learning software during the title/abstract screening to increase the efficiency of the process. Measurement tools, sampling and data collection methods, gap areas (geographical, topical and contextual), and indicators were catalogued for easy access in an interactive Tableau dashboard. Results Our search yielded 27,197 publications and 2396 non peer-reviewed literature reports. One hundred and seventy publications were included in the final review. Extracted indicators were categorized into seven domains: economic, health, human development, leadership, psychological, security and justice, and sociocultural. The vast majority of studies were observational, and over 70% utilized a cross-sectional study design. Thirty-eight toolkits and questionnaires were identified in this review, of which 19 (50%) were designed specifically for humanitarian settings. Sociocultural was the largest domain in number of studies and indicators in this review, with gender-based violence indicators reported in 66% of studies. Indicators of economic, human development and leadership were uncommon in the peer-reviewed literature. Discussion While there has been some effort to measure GEWE in conflict-affected and other humanitarian settings, measurement has largely focused on violence and security issues. A more comprehensive framework for measuring GEWE in these settings is needed; objective measurement of women’s empowerment and gender equality should be prioritized by organizations providing humanitarian aid.

Identifying the Preparedness Components for Sexual Violence in Natural Disasters: A Systematic Review

“…Other studies have reported that social norms in some societies and fear of social stigma are one of the barriers to accessing health services after sexual violence, requiring to be changed before the occurrence of disasters ( 67 - 69 ), which is in line with the present study. The expectations of men in society can lead them to believe that they can abuse women and justify their actions; therefore, changing the norms is effective in reducing the rate of sexual violence; to this end, it is necessary to change the norms before disasters ( 70 ). Another important measure for the proper management of sexual violence is the creation of information circulation systems, and it is necessary to take technical measures to establish a system for collecting information ( 71 ), which is also consistent with the current study.…”

“…These results are consistent with the results of the present study. Given that sexual violence is taboo in many societies, reporting is an important challenge in this regard, and defining the reporting process based on the cultural sensitivities of that society can be a good solution ( 70 , 76 ).…”

Factors Affecting Women Empowerment: A Micro Financing Perspective

“…( 2) Relational empowerment refers to the freedom of making decisions, free mobility, social circles, and response to haphazard situations individually or collectively. (3) Societal aspect denotes women's ratios opting for microfinance and rations of women successfully leading the microfinance firms (Goulart, Purewal, Nakhuda, Giancola, Kortenaar & Bassani, 2021;Lee et al, 2021). This model has built its foundation on ecological system theory (Bronfenbrenner, 1994) which implies that individuals starting from their childhood become a part of different environments that form their personalities and experiences.…”

Identifying the landscape of developmental toxicity new approach methodologies

“…While the identification and prioritization of the necessary references are critical to the development of the scoping report, an equally important aspect is the dissemination and exploration of the information contained within each reference. A few papers in recent years have utilized some visualization tools in health science scoping reports, such as Chishtie et al ( 2020 ), Goulart et al ( 2021 ), and Jornod et al ( 2021 ), to visualize health outcome information. While these tools are helpful, we chose to use other tools that were more fit‐for‐purpose to project needs.…”