“Tort Tales” and TV Judges: Amplifying, Modifying, or Countering the Antitort Narrative?

Abstract

This article joins the debate about the popular pervasiveness of antitort and antilitigation attitudes by examining whether, and to what extent, antitort or antilitigation sentiment is present in the narratives about law offered by reality‐based television judge shows. Given the persistent debate about tort reform and scholars' recognition of the role played in this debate by simplified narratives about the legal system, we analyze whether reality‐based TV judge shows as a genre contribute to the creation and dissemination antitort and antilitigation sentiment. Earlier studies led us to hypothesize that TV judge shows would largely support the antitort and antilitigation narratives. After coding over 55 hours of such shows, however, we conclude that they do not adopt this narrative. Rather, these shows present a view of the civil law system that largely treats plaintiffs' claims as legitimate and showcases the majority of defendants as wrongdoers. In spite of this, we argue that the particular dramatic qualities of TV judge shows limit their potential to serve as a strong counternarrative to antitort and antilitigation stories.

Settlement schemas: How laypeople understand civil settlement

“…Prior work has found that the public's primary source of information about the legal system is the news media (Yankelovich & White, Inc., 1978) and that television and other entertainment programming also play a role (Wilson & Ackerman, 2012). Although it is easier to think of entertainment portrayals of trials, there are also notable instances of settlements, for example, Erin Brockovich (Soderberg, 2000).…”

The Illegal Business of Human Trafficking

“…Examples of the impact of popular culture on legal consciousness abound. For example, "tort tales", TV judge shows, and crime dramas have figured prominently in debates about legal issues (Haltom and McCann 2004;Elkins 2007;Wilson and Ackerman 2012;Tyler 2006). Depictions of crime shape the social construction of criminality and legality (Mason 2003).…”

Primetime Dispute Resolution: Reality TV Mediation Shows in China's “Harmonious Society”

“…Compare the interesting studies of representation on the American court TV shows Judge Judy, Judge Joe Brown and The People's Court byKohm (2006); andWilson and Ackerman (2012).…”