The catabolism of methanol, formate, or carbon monoxide to acetate or butyrate or both was examined in two acetogenic bacteria. Butyribacterium methylotrophicum simultaneously transformed methanol and formate mainly to butyrate with concomitant H2 and CO2 production and consumption. In contrast, methanol plus CO was primarily converted to acetate, and only slight amounts of CO2 were produced. In vivo 13C nuclear magnetic resonance analysis of [13C]methanol transformation by B. methylotrophicum indicated that methanol was predominantly incorporated into the methyl of acetate, 13C02 was produced and then consumed, and butyrate was formed from the condensation of two acetate precursors. The analysis of the position of acetate labeled by a given 13C single-carbon substrate when B. methylotrophicum or Acetobacterium woodii was grown in the presence of a second one-carbon substrate indicated two trends: when methanol was consumed, CO, CO2, or formate predominantly labeled the acetate carboxyl; when CO was consumed, CO2 and formate were principally funneled into the acetate methyl group, and CO remained a better carboxyl precursor. These data suggest a model of acetate synthesis via the combined operation of two readily reversible single-carbon pathways which are linked by CO2. Anaerobic acetate-producing bacteria are generally referred to as acetogens (20). Besides using saccharides, most of the known acetogens also ferment single-carbon compounds to acetate, and under certain conditions, some produce butyrate (14, 41) and caproate (14). Bacterial growth on single-parbon substrates as both carbon and energy sources has been termed unicarbonotrophy (40). Most of the information on acetogen singlecarbon transformations derives from analysis of the glucose catabolism of Clostridium thermoaceticum (20). In this anaerobe, approximately one of every three acetates originates from two pyruvate carboxyl moieties. One pyruvate carboxyl yields the methyl group of acetate via CO2 and its subsequent reduction through free formate (2, 33), tetrahydrofolate (THF) derivatives (3, 24), and finally corrinoid one-carbon carriers (19, 37). The acetate carboxyl arises from the second pyruvate carboxyl group directly, without the involvement of free CO2 (29). Recent results of Drake et al. (12) and Hu et al. (15) indicate that CO also serves as an acetate carboxyl precursor in C. thermoaceticum cell