Traffickers, Brokers, Employment Agents, and Social Networks: The Regulation of Intermediaries in the Migration of Ethiopian Domestic Workers to the Middle East

Abstract

This paper examines the regulatory regimes surrounding the operations of intermediaries who facilitate Ethiopian women's employment as contract domestic workers in the Middle East. Drawing on empirical research in Ethiopia, Lebanon, and Kuwait, the paper focuses on the commonly observed problem of "regulatory failure," as states and international agencies frequently fail to achieve their objectives in the regulation of intermediaries of migration. This paper argues that a decentered approach to regulation can provide a productive diagnosis of regulatory failure, one that recognizes how power may be dispersed between social actors and (non-unitary) state actors and how it is differentially exercised across multiple regulatory regimes within this migration trajectory.

Ethical brokerage and self-fashioning in Italian immigration bureaucracy

“…Finally, Lindquist's work on petugas lapangan (PL), who work as field agents in labour migration brokerage in Indonesia, also disrupts the dichotomies of "victims" and "perpetrators" which frame debates around transnational migration (2012: 75). In his account, brokers were migrants themselves in the past, and some become migrants again in the future (see also Fernandez 2013).…”

Transformations in Network Governance: The Case of Migration Intermediaries

“…While there is an extensive scholarship examining the 'illegitimate' side of migration intermediaries, such as traffickers of irregular migrants and refugees (Fernandez 2013;Leman and Janssens 2007;Salt and Stein, 1997;Triandafyllidou and Maroukis 2012), to date, little is known about the various agents servicing the needs of skilled migrants. There is also, at best, a partial understanding of why and how they have emerged and the implications of the relations forged between intermediaries and skilled migrants.…”

The impact of government regulation on recruitment process, rights, wages and working conditions of labor migrants in the Israeli construction sector

“…The shift to a largely market-driven system of labor migrant recruitment fomented the proliferation of a large industry of private agents and intermediaries (Ellman, 2003;Agunias, 2009;Minghuan, 2012;Fernandez, 2013). The shift to a largely market-driven system of labor migrant recruitment fomented the proliferation of a large industry of private agents and intermediaries (Ellman, 2003;Agunias, 2009;Minghuan, 2012;Fernandez, 2013).…”