The transport and
recombination properties of dye-sensitized solar
cells based on phase-pure anatase and brookite nanomaterials are compared
as a function of the surface chemistry and morphology. Phase-pure
brookite has been synthesized from amorphous TiO2 using
two different solutions at low and high pH, resulting in different
size and morphology of brookite nanoparticles. The smaller short-circuit
current density (J
SC = 6.6 mA cm–2) for acidic brookite compared to anatase (9.8 mA cm–2) was related to the light harvesting efficiency because of the lower
amount of dye adsorbed. However, a larger open-circuit voltage for
acidic brookite indicates the promise of the material. The basic brookite-based
solar cells gave a very low J
SC (0.10
mA cm–2), which increased dramatically by a factor
of about 30 after an acid treatment of the films, illustrating the
effect of surface chemistry. A combination of experiments shows that
the improvement is related to an increase in injection efficiency.
Electrochemical impedance and intensity-modulated photocurrent and
photovoltage spectroscopies show that electron transport is faster
in the acid-treated basic brookite nanomaterial, related to the larger
feature sizes. However, the recombination kinetics is also significantly
faster, with as net result a smaller diffusion length and hence smaller
collection efficiency.