Transition in care from paramedics to emergency department nurses: a systematic review protocol

Abstract

BackgroundEffective and efficient transitions in care between emergency medical services (EMS) practitioners and emergency department (ED) nurses is vital as poor clinical transitions in care may place patients at increased risk for adverse events such as delay in treatment for time sensitive conditions (e.g., myocardial infarction) or worsening of status (e.g., sepsis). Such transitions in care are complex and prone to communication errors primarily caused by misunderstanding related to divergent professional perspectives leading to misunderstandings that are further susceptible to contextual factors and divergent professional lenses. In this systematic review, we aim to examine (1) factors that mitigate or improve transitions in care specifically from EMS practitioners to ED nurses, and (2) effectiveness of interventional strategies that lead to improvements in communication and fewer adverse events.MethodsWe will search electronic databases (DARE, MEDLINE, EMBASE, Cochrane, CINAHL, Joanna Briggs Institute EBP; Communication Abstracts); gray literature (gray literature databases, organization websites, querying experts in emergency medicine); and reference lists and conduct forward citation searches of included studies. All English-language primary studies will be eligible for inclusion if the study includes (1) EMS practitioners or ED nurses involved in transitions for arriving EMS patients; and (2) an intervention to improve transitions in care or description of factors that influence transitions in care (barriers/facilitators, perceptions, experiences, quality of information exchange). Two reviewers will independently screen titles/abstracts and full texts for inclusion and methodological quality. We will use narrative and thematic synthesis to integrate and explore relationships within the data. Should the data permit, a meta-analysis will be conducted.DiscussionThis systematic review will help identify factors that influence communication between EMS and ED nurses during transitions in care, and identify interventional strategies that lead to improved communication and decrease in adverse events. The findings can be used to develop an evidence-informed transitions in care tool that ensures efficient transfer of accurate patient information, continuity of care, enhances patient safety, and avoids duplication of services. This review will also identify gaps in the existing literature to inform future research efforts.Trial registrationPROSPERO CRD42017068844

Review article: Pre‐hospital provider clinical judgement upon arrival to the emergency department: A systematic review and meta‐analysis

“…Previous systematic reviews have focused on PHP‐initiated non‐transport – where insufficient evidence to support PHP‐initiated non‐transport was found, 3 pre‐hospital trauma triage – with similar findings 4 and ongoing research is focused towards information transfer from PHPs to hospital clinicians 5 . However, the accuracy of pre‐hospital assessment to be used in prediction of clinical course in the ED have not been previously synthesised.…”

Experiences of pre-hospital emergency medical personnel in ethical decision-making: a qualitative study

“…Medical emergency system is a part of the chain system in the care of patients and it continues from the time of the event to the patient’s rehabilitation and discharge [2]. Its purpose is to provide care, ensure immediate transfer of patients, and reduce mortality [3]. In dangerous and unpredictable care situations, ambulance professionals are often faced with situations in which decision-making puts them under heavy pressure, especially when they are faced with ethical challenges [4].…”

Conflitos entre as equipes de saúde na transferência do cuidado pré-hospitalar

“…Além disso, enfermeiras do departamento de emergência realizavam a triagem do paciente sobre as macas do serviço pré-hospitalar e, por vezes, eram interrompidas por outros profissionais, aumentando o tempo de espera dos paramédicos para transferir o paciente, bem como ocupando uma maca necessária para outros atendimentos. Uma das principais causas dessa demora está atribuída à superlotação dos departamentos de emergência, acarretando fadiga e sobrecarga de trabalho para ambos profissionais 7,20,21 .…”