“…This is equivalent to 0.3 electrons per WO 3 formula unit which would need an oxygen-vacancy concentration of ≈5%, if due solely to electron donation from oxygen vacancies, i.e., a vacancy concentration more than 30 times larger than observed. This is a surprising result since it is known that chemical doped WO 3 shows metallic behavior only for large concentrations of dopants, e.g., x > 0.08 for In x WO 3 [23,27] and even x > 0.25-0.3 for Na x WO 3 , [28][29][30] i.e., the number of carriers associated with the oxygen vacancies in IL gated WO 3 is about ten times smaller than the amount of Indium needed to metallize In x WO 3 and about 30 times below that needed to metallize WO 3 by Na doping. To understand this apparent contradiction, we use X-ray photoelectron spectroscopy (XPS) and Raman studies to explore changes in electronic structure and bonding.…”