Metrics & MoreArticle RecommendationsT he paper by Liberatore et al. is an interesting study showing the instability of GenX, a perfluorooctanoic acid alternative, in aprotic polar solvents such as acetonitrile, acetone, and dimethyl sulfoxide. 1 The authors discussed the reasons for the instability and possible chemical processes, but we would like to raise some further points.The authors proposed that proton dissociation, autodecarboxylation, and solvent-mediated proton transfer lead to the decomposition of GenX in aprotic solvents. However, proton dissociation can also occur in protic solvents (e.g., methanol and water) and GenX (pK a = 2.84), which is a strong acid like other per-and polyfluoroalkyl substances, appears to be mostly dissociated in aqueous solutions. 2 Furthermore, hydronium ions formed from water in the presence of protons can transfer protons to other molecules (Figure 1A). Thus, these processes do not appear to be important because GenX showed almost no decomposition in aqueous solutions. Taking acetone as an example, we find it is reasonable to assume that the oxygen atom in the carbonyl group is first protonated by an acid catalyst under acidic conditions (Figure 1B). However, solvent-mediated proton transfer occurs and a resonance-stabilized carbocation is generated. As a result, the Lewis acidity of the carbonyl compound may be increased, allowing a nucleophile to attack the carbonyl carbon. Although the carbanion produced by GenX decarboxylation is relatively stable, it is considered a potent nucleophile. This carbanion may react with the carbocation of protonated acetone. In addition, even if the formation of a carbocation is rare under these conditions, if the carbanion produced from GenX causes an attack on the carbonyl carbon of acetone, then an addition reaction can occur (Figure 1C). This occurs because even if GenX causes the transfer of a proton to acetone, the amount of protonated acetone is very small compared with the total amount of acetone as a solvent. In fact, the trichloromethyl anion produced by the decarboxylation of trichloroacetate salt is used as a nucleophile in chemical reactions. 3 However, in the authors' experiments, only Fluoroether E-1 was produced, at almost 100%, even when acetone was used, and no products of an addition reaction were observed in acetone. Therefore, it seems difficult to reconcile the proposed mechanism from the observations of the authors. Future studies, including molecular dynamics simulations to study the decarboxylation mechanism, will be required. 4 Kouji H. Harada orcid.org/0000-0001-7319-123X