Dedicated to Professor Gottfried Huttner on the occasion of his 68th birthdayPhosphinidenes, that is, carbene-analogous compounds of monovalent phosphorus (phosphanylidenes, RÀP) represent a simple class of valuable electrophilic building blocks in organophosphorus chemistry, which are usually highly reactive transients and therefore difficult to isolate. [1] However, one simple chemical trick that aids the preparation of a room-temperature stable phosphinidene is the intra-or intermolecular addition of a donor group D to the initially electron-deficient phosphorus atom (D!PR); this affords an electron-rich (nucleophilic) phosphinidene, having eight or more valence electrons at the phosphorus center. Several types of donor-stabilized phosphinidenes have already been isolated and used as versatile precursors for the preparation of "free" phosphinidenes such as phospha-Wittig reagents (R 3 P = PR') [2] and related phosphinidene metal complexes (L n M = PR).[3] The intramolecular donor-stabilization of a P(+1) atom is also the reason for the intriguing stability of the nucleophilic phosphinidene 1 (Scheme 1), which has a planar, T-shaped three-coordinate phosphorus atom with 10 valence electrons (10-P-3 system).[4] Although 1 is a promising versatile building block for the synthesis of novel electronically tunable organophosphorus ligands, its reactivity has only been sparingly investigated.[5] The relatively high nucleophilicity at the P atom prompted us to investigate whether alkylation of phosphorus with classical alkylation reagents RX (R = alkyl; X = anionic leaving group) leads to a nucleophilic phosphenium salt A, phosphonium species B, or neutral phosphorane C as possible valence isomers, depending on the electronic nature and steric demand of R and X, respectively (Scheme 1).Here we report the surprising formation of the unusual phosphonium cage cation in 2, which results from a domino cyclization of two molecules of 1 in the presence of methyl trifluoromethylsulfonate (MeOTf). When a solution of MeOTf in CH 2 Cl 2 was added to a solution of 1 in CH 2 Cl 2 in the molar ratio of 1:1 at 20 8C, a rapid reaction occurs ( 31 P NMR monitoring), affording the unexpected phosphonium salt 2 [Eq. (1)]. The latter is insoluble in hydrocarbon solvents and other nonpolar solvents and can be isolated in the form of a colorless solid in 35 % yield. The yield can be increased up to 78 % by changing the molar ratio of the starting materials MeOTf and 1 to 1:2. Interestingly, compound 2 results also exclusively even if a solution of 1 in CH 2 Cl 2 is slowly added to a very large molar excess or even by using neat MeOTf at room temperature or below (À10 8C). The composition and constitution of 2 was established by EI-FAB and ESI (electrospray ionization) mass spectrometry Scheme 1. The possible valence isomers A, B, and C formed by alkylation of 1 with RX (R = alkyl, X = anionic leaving group; ET = electron transfer.