U.S. medical school admissions and enrollment practices: status of LGBTQ inclusivity

Abstract

Context The failure to collect information on lesbian, gay, bisexual, transgender, and queer (LGBTQ) identity in healthcare and medical education is a part of a systemic problem that limits academic medical institutions’ ability to address LGBTQ health disparities. Objectives To determine whether accurate sexual and gender minority (SGM) demographic data is being consistently collected for all US medical schools during admissions and enrollment, and whether differences exist between collection practices at osteopathic and allopathic schools. Methods Secure, confidential electronic were sent via email in July 2019 to 180 osteopathic (n=42) and allopathic (n=138) medical schools identified through the American Association of Colleges of Osteopathic Medicine Student Guide to Osteopathic Medical Colleges database and the American Association of Medical Colleges Medical School Admissions Requirements database. The nine question survey remained open through October 2019 and queried for; (1) the ability of students to self report SGM status during admissions and enrollment; and (2) availability of SGM specific resources and support services for students. Chi square analysis and the test for equality of proportions were performed. Results Seventy five of 180 (41.7%) programs responded to the survey; 74 provided at least partial data. Of the 75 respondent schools, 55 (73.3%) allowed applicants to self report a gender identity other than male or female, with 49 (87.5%) of those being allopathic schools compared with 6 (31.6%) osteopathic schools. Similarly, 15 (20.0%) allowed applicants to report sexual orientation, with 14 (25.5%) of those being allopathic schools compared with one (5.3%) osteopathic school. Fifty four of 74 (73.0%) programs allowed matriculants to self report a gender identity other than male or female; 11 of 74 (14.7%) allowed matriculants to report sexual orientation. Conclusions Demographics collection practices among American medical education programs that responded to our survey indicated that they undervalued sexual orientation and gender identity, with osteopathic programs being less likely than allopathic programs to report inclusive best practices in several areas. American medical education programs, and their supervising bodies, must update their practices with respect to the collection of sexual orientation and gender identity demographics as part of a holistic effort to address SGM health disparities.

A Content Analysis of Osteopaths’ Attitudes for a More Inclusive Clinical Practice towards Transgender People

“…For example, a recently published survey revealed that American medical education institutions undervalued sexual orientation and gender identity in demographic collection procedures, with osteopathic programs reporting less inclusive best practices in several areas than allopathic programs. As part of a comprehensive effort to address sexual and gender minority health inequalities, healthcare education institutions must alter their methods to collect sexual orientation and gender identity demographics [ 62 ].…”

The sexual and gender minority (LGBTQ+) medical trainee: the journey through medical education

“…For many LGBTQ + trainees, finding a welcoming and diverse school is crucial to their application. Demographic data collection of SGM students from medical school admission and enrollment processes is undervalued [ 34 ]. Certain institutional climates can be perceived as non-inclusive and unwelcoming to minorities.…”

Strategies For Enhancing Equity, Diversity, and Inclusion in Medical School Admissions–A Canadian Medical School's Journey

“…Within Canada, there is underrepresentation of physicians who are Indigenous, racialized (especially Black, Filipino), of rural origin, with disabilities, and with socioeconomically challenged backgrounds (24)(25)(26). Physician data on diversity parameters such as sexual identity, immigration status, and language diversity are lacking (24)(25)(26)(27).…”