In modified theories of gravity including a critical acceleration scale a 0 , a critical length scale r M = (GM/a 0 ) 1/2 will naturally arise with the transition from the Newtonian to the dark matter mimicking regime occurring for systems larger than r M . This adds a second critical scale to gravity, in addition to the one introduced by the criterion v < c of the Schwarzschild radius, r S = 2GM/c 2 . The distinct dependencies of the two above length scales give rise to non-trivial phenomenology in the (mass, length) plane for astrophysical structures, which we explore here. Surprisingly, extrapolation to atomic scales suggests gravity should be at the dark matter mimicking regime there.