Understanding of and adherence to advice after telephone counselling by nurse: a survey among callers to a primary emergency out-of-hours service in Norway

Abstract

BackgroundTo investigate how callers understand the information given by telephone by registered nurses in a casualty clinic, to what degree the advice was followed, and the final outcome of the condition for the patients.MethodsThe study was conducted at a large out-of-hours inter-municipality casualty clinic in Norway during April and May 2010. Telephone interviews were performed with 100 callers/patients who had received information and advice by a nurse as a sole response. Six topics from the interview guide were compared with the telephone record files to check whether the caller had understood the advice. In addition, questions were asked about how the caller followed the advice provided and the patient's outcome.Results99 out of 100 interviewed callers stated that they had understood the nurse's advice, but interpreted from the telephone records, the total agreement for all six topics was 82.6%. 93 callers/patients stated that they followed the advice and 11 re-contacted the casualty clinic. 22 contacted their GP for the same complaints the same week, of whom five patients received medical treatment and one was hospitalised. There were significant difference between the native-Norwegian and the non-native Norwegian regarding whether they trusted the nurse (p = 0.017), and if they got relevant answers to their questions (p = 0.005).ConclusionCallers to the out-of-hours service seem to understand the advice given by the registered nurses, and a large majority of the patients did not contact their GP or other health services again with the same complaints.Practice ImplicationMedical and communicative training must be an important part of the continuous improvement strategy within the out-of-hour services.

Emergency Department Attendance after Telephone Triage: A Population‐Based Data Linkage Study

“…). These services may be designed for patients of health care facilities (Hansen and Hunskaar ; Campbell et al. ), health maintenance organizations (O'Connell et al.…”

“…Some of the existing research relies on self‐reporting to measure compliance (Kempe et al. ; Hansen and Hunskaar ; O'Cathain et al. ), which is subject to recall and social desirability biases.…”

“…of health care facilities (Hansen and Hunskaar 2011;Campbell et al 2014), health maintenance organizations (O'Connell et al 2002;Kempe et al 2006;Navratil-Strawn et al 2014), or a whole population (De Coster et al 2010) (Foster, Jessopp, and Chakraborti 2003;Labarere et al 2003). The population of NSW, Australia, has access to the healthdirect helpline telephone triage service and publicly funded universal health care, and some may access private health care.…”

Improvement of communication and interpersonal competence in telenursing – development of a self‐assessment tool

“…() analysed 41 calls involving malpractice claims in telenursing and found that the patient's understanding was only followed up in six cases. Researchers suggest that telenurses can check that the caller understands by asking the caller to repeat the advice given to ensure the patient safety (Hansen Holm & Hunskaar , Ernesäter et al . ).…”

Geographical barriers to education law advice: access, communications and public legal services in England and Wales

“…Related to criticism voiced in the Lords in the context of legal services, concerns have also been raised about comprehension and understanding of the advice patients receive (Dale et al . ; Hansen and Hunskaar ; Leclerc et al . ).…”