“…However, YbO is a semiconductor with a 0.32 eV band gap, and YbS is an insulator with a 1.40 eV band gap as determined by experiment. 29,30 While the MBJLDA calculation is crucial for the noninteracting topological insulators, 36 and describes accurately the correlation effects of the 5d states, it can't describe well those of the more localized 4 f states, whose treatment still requires an additional Hubbard U value. 37,38 The MBJLDA+U calculations with U of ∼ 3.0 eV render a band gap of ∼0.24 eV for YbO, while YbS needs a larger Hubbard U=7.0 eV to obtain a band gap of 1.26 eV.…”