University students’ heuristic usability ınspection of the national library of Turkey website

Abstract

Purpose The purpose of this paper is to evaluate the usability of the National Library of Turkey website developed for all citizens in the country to retrieve information available in a wide range of areas. Design/methodology/approach The evaluation performed by 57 undergraduate university students involved the identification and analysis of usability problems in the selected website. The assessment process was mainly based on Nielsen’s Heuristics. The data obtained in the evaluation process were enriched using the System Usability Scale (SUS) and the Net Promoter Score (NPS) to conduct a more detailed analysis. Findings The participants identified many usability problems concerning the evaluated website and considered it as having low usability characteristics. The most violated heuristic item was found to be “consistency and standards” whereas the least violated heuristic item was “match between system and the real world.” The total number of the usability problems in heuristic evaluation correlated significantly and negatively with the SUS and the NPS results indicating that the more participants identified usability problems, the less they considered the website as usable and recommendable. Research limitations/implications The participants were not usability experts, however they were selected from among the students who received the Human Computer Interaction course to ensure that they had sufficient information and experience concerning the evaluation of a website with heuristics. Besides, the study was limited to a small number of university students. The implication is that results of this study have potential to guide libraries, which plan to adapt themselves to the digital world by delivering web services, by addressing critical points influencing users’ points of views toward library websites and their usability evaluation result. Practical implications Depending on the changes in user habits regarding the retrieval of information, libraries have made considerable investments in web technologies to meet their users’ demands, and recently, digital libraries have begun to take over physical libraries. Users always need to perform tasks efficiently, effectively and satisfactorily when using websites. As one of the most crucial sources of digital materials, library websites are expected to have usable characteristics that satisfactorily meet user requirements. Therefore, the practical implication is that the findings of the study will guide designers, developers and practitioners in the development of library websites. Originality/value In the context of usability evaluation of digital libraries, this is the first study to analyze effects of usability problems identified by users during the heuristic inspection on their overall evaluation score and willingness to recommend the website to their friends or colleagues.

Digital library evaluation measures in academic settings: Perspectives from scholars and practitioners

“…Satisfaction was assessed from the perspectives of users’ reactions using a Likert scale. Inal (2018) employed a heuristics approach for digital library usability evaluation, and worked with 57 subjects who had sufficient knowledge of the evaluation of a website with heuristics. They inspected the usability of a digital library with a set of predefined heuristics with different levels of severity, ranging from cosmetic to minor, major, and catastrophic.…”

“…The majority of articles on measures are related to usability and accessibility studies of digital libraries (e.g. Inal, 2018; Jeng, 2005). The existing research and practice set a good foundation for this study.…”

Influence of the Net Promoter Score of Retailers on the Willingness of Consumers to Install Their Mobile App

“…Despite all the criticisms, NPS has been used several times from the beginning, not only in practice but also in research [27]- [31], [34], [35]. Originally developed by Ref.…”

“…Originally developed by Ref. [15] as a measure correlating with company growth, satisfaction the NPS is repeatedly used as a method for measuring customer, here expressed by the intention to recommend it as the highest form of customer satisfaction [28], [35], [36]. In this respect, the NPS may be regarded as one of the most popular methods in business practice for measuring customer satisfaction.…”

Impact of University Website Usability on Satisfaction: A Structural Equation Modelling Approach

“…The study also aims to understand the satisfaction with the usability of the website. In the Indian context, a majority of studies are related to the usability of the library website (Guay et al, 2019;Inal, 2018;Kalra & Verma, 2011;Pant, 2015;Preedip Balaji & Kumar, 2011;Silvis et al, 2019;Vasishta, 2013), but the current study tries to bridge the gap in the literature not only in a geographical context but also in the area of website usability dimensions and their association with the level of satisfaction from students' perspective.…”