Using Asynchronous, Online Discussion Forums to Explore How Life Sciences Students Approach an Ill-Structured Problem

Abstract

To foster students’ learning of critical-thinking skills, I previously introduced ill-structured problems to provide students opportunities to apply content knowledge and thinking skills. However, I noted that my third-year, life sciences students were not solving such problems effectively. Therefore, I used a grounded approach and conducted content analysis of students’ forum discussions to understand their problem-solving approaches. The students worked in small groups using asynchronous, online discussion forums (AODFs) to discuss their approaches to solving an ill-structured problem posed. Each group submitted their solution to the problem in an essay. From my analysis of students’ posts at AODFs, students seemed fairly competent in using domain-specific knowledge and certain domain-general skills in scientific argumentation. However, they lacked the ability to properly define the problem scope and, consequently, failed to address the problem adequately. The study illuminated students’ challenges and provided me possible ways to plan relevant scaffolds in subsequent iterations of the activity.

How chemists handle not-knowing in reasoning about a novel problem

“…Almost all chemistry instruction, including almost all assessment of student learning, has focused on what students know. Only recently have courses begun to adopt for example, the use of ill-structured problems (Jonassen, 1997;Landa et al, 2020;Yeong, 2021) to promote students' more sustained, engagement. This study supports the need for that shift of pedagogy and emphasis, in evidence of how experts' recognition of not-knowing motivates and guides their engagement.…”

Hybrid project-based learning for problem-solving skils and student creativity in plant anatomy and physiology courses

“…Students' answers in aspect of define and understand the problem Define and understand the problem is a basic component in problem solving.In finding solutions, problems need to be arranged systematically. Systematic preparation can start from understanding a problem and being able to identify problems that occur(Yeong, 2021). To help students understand a problem, it can be started by presenting a problem through pictures or other illustrative schemes for students(Powell, Berry, Benz, Forsyth, & Martinez-Lincoln, 2017).…”