Using Logistic Regression to Analyze the Sensitivity of PVA Models: a Comparison of Methods Based on African Wild Dog Models

Abstract

We used logistic regression as a method of sensitivity analysis for a stochastic population viability analysis model of African wild dogs ( Lycaon pictus ) and compared these results with conventional sensitivity analyses of stochastic and deterministic models. Standardized coefficients from the logistic regression analyses indicated that pup survival explained the most variability in the probability of extinction, regardless of whether or not the model incorporated density dependence. Adult survival and the standard deviation of pup survival were the next most important parameters in density-dependent simulations, whereas the severity and probability of catastrophe were more important during density-independent simulations. The inclusion of density dependence decreased the probability of extinction, but neither the abruptness nor the inclusion of density dependence were important model parameters. Results of both relative sensitivity analyses that altered each parameter by 10% of its range and life-stage-simulation analyses of deterministic matrix models supported the logistic regression results, indicating that pup survival and its variation were more important than other parameters. But both conventional sensitivity analysis of the stochastic model which changed each parameter by 10% of its mean value and elasticity analyses indicated that adult survival was more important than pup survival. We evaluated the advantages and disadvantages of using logistic regression to analyze the sensitivity of stochastic population viability models and conclude that it is a powerful method because it can address interactions among input parameters and can incorporate the range of parameter variability, although the standardized regression coefficients are not comparable between studies. Model structure, method of analysis, and parameter uncertainty affect the conclusions of sensitivity analyses. Therefore, rigorous model exploration and analysis should be conducted to understand model behavior and management implications.Utilización de la Regresión Logística para Analizar la Sensibilidad de Modelos de AVP: una Comparación de Métodos Basados en Modelos de Perros Silvestres Africanos Resumen: Utilizamos la regresión logística como un método de análisis de sensibilidad par a un modelo de análisis de viabilidad poblacional de perros silvestres Africanos ( Lycaon pictus ) y comparamos estos resultados con análisis de sensibilidad convencionales de modelos estocásticos y determinísticos. Coeficientes estandarizados de los análisis de regresión logística indicaron que la supervivencia de cachorros explicaba la mayor variabilidad en la probabilidad de extinción, independientemente de que el modelo incorporara la denso-dependencia. La supervivencia de adultos y la desviación estándar de la supervivencia de cachorros fueron los parámetros que siguieron en importancia en simulaciones de denso-dependencia, mientras que la severidad y la probabilidad de catástrofes fueron más importantes durante simulaciones denso-independientes. La inclu...

Modeling the eradication of invasive mammals using the sterile male technique

“…In particular, the analysis is important to identify why each control measure might be effective, and to help direct each control measure on the age class in which it will be most effective. According to Cross and Beissinger (2001) the best method for our type of The analysis suggests that survivorship during the adult stage (stages 2-17) is the most important factor contributing to population growth, being responsible for approximately 52% of k (Table 1). The results indicate why hunting is so effective at reducing k, while sterile males are not as effective on their own.…”

Simulating the effects of wolf-elk population dynamics on resource flow to scavengers

“…A Shannon diversity number of 0 indicates that all the carrion occurs in one month of the year whereas a value of 1 indicates that the carrion is evenly distributed across each month of the year. Sensitivity analyses were conducted using Monte Carlo methods to assess the relative effects of several parameters on model statistics (Wisdom and Mills, 1997;Wisdom et al, 2000;Cross and Beissinger, a Because of the extreme sensitivity to this parameter, we confined it to this narrow range. In addition, for the reasons discussed in Getz (1996), this parameter is likely to be small (i.e.…”

“…Mean yearly carrion levels and Shannon diversity numbers for the years 101-500 were recorded for each run and used as the dependent variable in linear regressions in which the model parameters were the explanatory variables. Model parameters were ranked according to r 2 values in order to determine which ones explained the most variance in model output statistics (Wisdom and Mills, 1997;Wisdom et al, 2000;Cross and Beissinger, 2001). The larger the range in a parameter, the higher its r 2 may become.…”

Modelling strategies for the management of the critically endangered Carpentarian rock-rat (Zyzomys palatalis) of northern Australia

“…However, by varying input parameter values and/or model structure, the consequences of different parameter conditions on a model population's dynamics can be investigated (Cross and Beissinger, 2001). Sensitivity analysis can be used to determine which parameters most strongly in¯uence model predictions when uncertainty exists, and are helpful in focusing researchers' efforts on improving estimates of the most important variables (Reed et al, 1998;Caswell, 2001).…”

“…However, in the simulation procedure we use, the signi®cance of the parameters is a function of the somewhat arbitrary sample size (McCarthy et al, 1996). Therefore, the magnitude of the regression coef®cients was used to determine the importance (sensitivity) of each parameter to the value of the dependent variable, scaled by the level of uncertainty (see Cross and Beissinger, 2001). …”