Using Mice to Model Human Disease: Understanding the Roles of Baseline Housing-Induced and Experimentally Imposed Stresses in Animal Welfare and Experimental Reproducibility

Abstract

Mice are the most common animal used to study disease, but there are real concerns about the reproducibility of many of these experiments. This review discusses how several different sources of chronic stress can directly impact experimental outcomes. Mandated housing conditions induce an underappreciated level of chronic stress but are not usually considered or reported as part of the experimental design. Since chronic stress plays a critical role in the development and progression of many somatic diseases including cancer, obesity, and auto-immune diseases, this baseline stress can directly affect outcomes of such experiments. To study the role of stress in both physical and psychiatric diseases, there has been a proliferation of protocols for imposing chronic stress on mice. For somatic diseases, biomarkers can be used to compare the models with the disease in patients, but to evaluate the validity of psychiatric models, behavioral tests are carried out to assess changes in behavior and these tests may themselves cause an underappreciated degree of additional stress. Therefore, it is important for animal welfare to reduce baseline stress and select the most humane protocols for inducing and assessing chronic stress to obtain the most reliable outcomes.

Systematic Analysis of Human Colorectal Cancer scRNA-seq Revealed Limited Pro-tumoral IL-17 Production Potential in Gamma Delta T Cells

“…In contrast, human γδ T cells display broader functional plasticity and are involved in more diverse roles 132 . Therefore, caution is warranted in interpreting results from mice models, as mouse γδ T cell responses, especially cytokine production, may not accurately reflect human γδ T cell responses, despite experimental and computational methods developed to address these discrepancies [133][134][135][136][137] .…”

Novel insights into metabolic‐associated steatotic liver disease preclinical models

“…The reproducibility and success of the experiments could be affected by some environmental and biological factors, such as human and mice interactions, injurious home‐cage aggression in mice 152 and difficulties due to a lack of standardized experimental protocols. Numerous studies have proven that chronic stress in mice is caused by cold housing temperature 153,154 and this chronic stress could lead to depression, anxiety, lack of social support or suppress immunity 155 . Generally, the standard temperature in laboratories is colder, mainly for human comfort (20‐23°C), whereas the thermoneutral temperature for mice oscillates between 30 and 32°C 156 .…”

Unified ethical principles and an animal research ‘Helsinki’ declaration as foundations for international collaboration

“…The effects of the laboratory environment on research outcomes has been highlighted by several authors (e.g. ( Mogil, 2017 ; Hylander et al, 2022 )). Addressing these concerns brings together improved welfare, often by reducing uncontrolled stress, and optimal study design.…”