“…Furthermore, analysis of the ground state properties by defining appropriate structure factors, suggests a plaquette valence bond solid (PVBS) ground state for 0.2 J 2 /J 1 0.35 which transforms to a valence bond solid (VBS) state with staggered dimerization at J 2 /J 1 ≈ 0.35 20,21 . The existence of plaquette valence bond solid has been verified by different methods, such as functional renormalization group 22 , coupled cluster method (CCM) 23,24 , mean-field plaquette valence bond theory 25,37 and density matrix renormalization group (DMRG) 26,27 . However, other methods such as Schwinger boson mean-field approach 28,29,32,33 , Schwinger fermion mean-field theory 30 and variational Monte Carlo 31 propose a Z 2 quantum spin liquid (QSL) for the disordered region.…”