Online instructors need to take on a multi-dimensional role and to be an effective online educator they are required to possess a varied and wider range of competencies. Preparing teachers for online education involves preparing them for a wide variety of roles and developing related competencies. However, the extent of emphasis required to be placed on each of these roles or competencies during a teacher training program may vary according to its culture and the context. The investigation reported in this article obtained expert opinions with regard to the priority and criticality of eight online instructor roles identified in earlier research on online education. Pedagogical roles received the highest priority by the respondents, followed by professional, evaluator, social facilitator, technologist, advisor, administrator, and researcher roles. These results have implications for teacher education and further research pertaining to the context in India.Keywords: instructor competency; online learning; teacher preparation Introduction Many teachers regard face-to-face communication as a preferred mode for teachinglearning, in spite of the dramatic progress taking place in online education. While online communication rarely makes emotions and gestures as explicit as they would be in a face-to-face context, it does have the potential for people to converse with intensity, depth, and meaning. Klein, Spector, Grabowski, and de la Teja (2004), while developing competencies for online instructors, re-examined the competencies for face-to-face settings and came to the conclusion that competencies for online instructors were not substantially different from those in face-to-face settings at a high level of abstraction. This may also imply that certain levels of equivalence exist between the instructors involved in these two modes of education. In other words, the competencies and roles required to teach in an online environment are not fundamentally different from those for teaching in a face-to-face situation. For example, listening skills are important in both contexts. However, the significance and demonstration of these competencies may vary according to the context or the roles one is assumed to undertake while teaching. That is to say, that how a teacher listens effectively in different contexts may require different skills.