Stable Fe isotopes have only recently been measured in
freshwater
systems, mainly in meromictic lakes. Here we report the δ56Fe of dissolved, particulate, and sediment Fe in two small
dimictic boreal shield headwater lakes: manipulated eutrophic Lake
227, with annual cyanobacterial blooms, and unmanipulated oligotrophic
Lake 442. Within the lakes, the range in δ56Fe is
large (ca. −0.9 to +1.8‰), spanning more than half the
entire range of natural Earth surface samples. Two layers in the water
column with distinctive δ56Fe of dissolved (dis)
and particulate (spm) Fe were observed, despite differences in trophic
states. In the epilimnia of both lakes, a large Δ56Fedis‑spm fractionation of 0.4–1‰
between dissolved and particulate Fe was only observed during cyanobacterial
blooms in Lake 227, possibly regulated by selective biological uptake
of isotopically light Fe by cyanobacteria. In the anoxic layers in
both lakes, upward flux from sediments dominates the dissolved Fe
pool with an apparent Δ56Fedis‑spm fractionation of −2.2 to −0.6‰. Large Δ56Fedis‑spm and previously published metagenome
sequence data suggest active Fe cycling processes in anoxic layers,
such as microaerophilic Fe(II) oxidation or photoferrotrophy, could
regulate biogeochemical cycling. Large fractionation of stable Fe
isotopes in these lakes provides a potential tool to probe Fe cycling
and the acquisition of Fe by cyanobacteria, with relevance for understanding
biogeochemical cycling of Earth’s early ferruginous oceans.