“…Consequently, the adjustments from 2003 to 2007 were mainly reductions of the rates of VAT rebates for high energy-consuming and high polluting products (e.g., steel products, pesticide, chlorine and other chemical products), and resource-based products (e.g., rare earth metals, silicon and wooden products). As documented by Braakmann et al (2020), the adjustments during this period were indeed related to product characteristics, such as whether the product is resource-intensive, high-tech, pollutive and energy-consuming, but were unrelated to various measures of export shocks.…”