The subtropical North Atlantic is a key region for understanding climate impact in the ocean. Plankton studies in this region have been generally framed in biogeographic provinces or focused on latitudinal gradients. In this study, we demonstrate the benefits of using empirically constructed continuous gradients versus the use of average values for biogeographical provinces to characterize plankton assemblages along a longitudinal transect at 24.5° N using an unprecedented array of stations including hydrographic observations, abundance of phytoplankton and zooplankton, and plankton size spectra in the epipelagic layer (0–200 m). In addition, the variability of zooplankton assemblages was analyzed using detailed taxonomic identification at selected stations. We found significant gradients in most hydrographic and plankton variables. The former, including surface temperature and salinity, the depth of the upper mixing layer, and the depth of the chlorophyll maximum, displayed non-linear gradients with maximum or minimum values near the center of the transect. In contrast, most plankton variables showed linear zonal gradients. Phytoplankton, microzooplankton (<100 µm), and the slope and the intercept of the size spectra increased (and Trichodesmium decreased) to the west. Total mesozooplankton (>200 µm) did not show any significant zonal pattern, but the taxonomic assemblages were characterized by a gradual replacement of large Calanoids by small-bodied Cyclopoid copepods from east to west. The use of continuous gradients provides more detailed information on the zonal structure of subtropical plankton than the classical approach using discrete areas.