Victimization of People With Severe Mental Illness Outside and Within the Mental Health Care System: Results on Prevalence and Risk Factors From a Multicenter Study

Abstract

We performed a cross-sectional study using a self-reporting survey to assess lifetime violent and non-violent victimization in people with severe mental illness experienced both inside (i.e., any service providing mental health care such as psychiatric hospitals, psychosocial rehabilitative programs, or outpatient care) and outside (i.e., in the personal life of the participants) of the mental health care system. We recruited 170 participants from 20 community mental health facilities. We built logistic regression models to assess potential risk factors for victimization inside the mental health care system. Outside of the mental health care system, the most commonly reported events were theft (n=93, 54.7%), physical violence without use of a weapon (n=87, 51.2%), and sexual harassment (n=82, 50.6%). Within the mental health care system, most commonly reported incidents were theft (n=68, 40.0%), sexual assault (n=18, 10.6%), and physical violence (n=47, 27.7%) by other patients or staff. Significant risk factors for specific victimization events inside the mental health care system were psychotic disorder, victimization in childhood and youth, female gender, number of hospitalizations, and duration of illness. Findings call for increased attention to victimization of people with severe mental illness, especially within the mental health care system as such victimization events may severely impact patients' trajectories. Keywords: victimization in psychiatry, risk factors for violence in mental health care system, illegal offences against patients, violence in mental health care system, patients as victims

Experiences and challenges faced by community mental health workers when providing care to people with mental illness: a qualitative study

“…During a psychotic episode, the patient's lack of recognition and control over their behavior may lead to violent incidents [13]. However, people with mental illness are at much higher risk of becoming victims of violence than those who commit violence [53][54][55]. Health care interventions can be effective in preventing violent behavior in people with mental illness [54].…”

Sexuelle Übergriffe in psychiatrischen Kliniken

“…Die hohe Gewaltbetroffenheit von Frauen wurde im Rahmen einer Erhebung in stationären und ambulanten psychiatrischen Einrichtungen in Süddeutschland bestätigt, bei der 170 Personen mit schweren psychischen Erkrankungen befragt wurden: jede zweite Frau berichtete mindestens eine Vergewaltigung (Männer: 11 %), 71 % der Frauen sexuelle Belästigungen (Männer: 26 %), 61 % körperliche Gewalt (Männer: 44 %) und 18 % gaben an, schon einmal mit einer Waffe bedroht worden zu sein (Männer: 10 %) [7].…”

Media stereotyping of vulnerable groups in Serbia

“…Анализа медијских презентација особа са менталним сметњама потврђује да су вести које се на њих односе по правилу негативне, изразито сензационалиситчке (при чему текст обично прати узнемирујући графички приказ окрвављеног оруђа и слично), те да их упадљиво повезују са бруталним насиљем, односно сугеришу директну везу између менталног поремећаја и насилности. Ова лица најчешће се представљају као извршиоци екстремног, немотивисаног и непредвидљивог насиља, а врло ретко као жртве, што је у раскораку са реалним стањем ствари, имајући у виду налазе криминолошких студија који указују на то да се особе са менталним сметњама по правилу налазе у већем ризику од насилне виктимизације у односу на општу популацију (Rossa-Roccor, Schmid, Steinert, 2020), као и да чешће страдају од насиља него што га врше (Ghiasi, Azhar, Singh, 2021).…”