The Visible-Infrared Mapping Spectrometer (VIR) on board the Dawn spacecraft revealed that aqueous secondary minerals-Mg-phyllosilicates, NH 4-bearing phases, and Mg/Ca carbonatesare ubiquitous on Ceres. Ceres' low reflectance requires dark phases, which were assumed to be amorphous carbon and/or magnetite (∼80 wt.%). In contrast, the Gamma Ray and Neutron Detector (GRaND) constrained the abundances of C (8-14 wt.%) and Fe (15-17 wt.%). Here, we reconcile the VIR-derived mineral composition with the GRaND-derived elemental composition. First, we model mineral abundances from VIR data, including either meteorite-derived insoluble organic matter (IOM), amorphous carbon, magnetite, or combination as the darkening agent and provide statistically rigorous error bars from a Bayesian algorithm combined with a radiative-transfer model. Elemental abundances of C and Fe are much higher than is suggested by the GRaND observations for all models satisfying VIR data. We then show that radiative transfer modeling predicts higher reflectance from a carbonaceous chondrite of known composition than its measured reflectance. Consequently, our second models use multiple carbonaceous chondrite endmembers, allowing for the possibility that their specific textures or minerals other than carbon or magnetite act as darkening agents, including sulfides and tochilinite. Unmixing models with carbonaceous chondrites eliminate the discrepancy in elemental abundances of C and Fe. Ceres' average reflectance spectrum and elemental abundances are best reproduced by carbonaceouschondrite-like materials (40-70 wt.%), IOM or amorphous carbon (10 wt.%), magnetite (3-8 wt.%), serpentine (10-25 wt.%), carbonates (4-12 wt.%), and NH 4-bearing phyllosilicates (1-11 wt.%). Plain Language Summary Ceres is a dwarf planet and the largest object in the main asteroid belt, consisting of ice and assemblages of hydrous minerals that incorporate water, ammonium, and carbon. An open question about Ceres is its surface composition and the nature of the materials that make its surface very dark. Whereas iron oxides and amorphous carbon have been suggested from the analyses of spectra at infrared wavelengths of light and mixture modeling using pure mineral or organic endmembers, elemental analysis independently found that C and Fe are not as abundant as posited by these analyses. Thus, another phase or set of phases must be responsible. The dark nature of Ceres is similar to the dark nature of carbonaceous chondrite meteorites, measured in laboratory. We find that the tiny nanometer-and micrometer-scale of darkening agents in these meteorites is not well-accounted for by existing physics-based mixture models of mineral and organic endmembers. Consequently, we use a spectral unmixing model that involves minerals, organics and carbonaceous chondrite meteorites to show that Ceres' surface contains multiple darkening agents of the style found in carbonaceous-chondrite meteorites and additional carbon, hydrous minerals, carbonates, and NH 4-bearing minerals.