Weaving seams with data: Conceptualizing City APIs as elements of infrastructures

Abstract

This article addresses the role of application programming interfaces (APIs) for integrating data sources in the context of smart cities and communities. On top of the built infrastructures in cities, application programming interfaces allow to weave new kinds of seams from static and dynamic data sources into the urban fabric. Contributing to debates about ''urban informatics'' and the governance of urban information infrastructures, this article provides a technically informed and critically grounded approach to evaluating APIs as crucial but often overlooked elements within these infrastructures.The conceptualization of what we term City APIs is informed by three perspectives: In the first part, we review established criticisms of proprietary social media APIs and their crucial function in current web architectures. In the second part, we discuss how the design process of APIs defines conventions of data exchanges that also reflect negotiations between API producers and API consumers about affordances and mental models of the underlying computer systems involved. In the third part, we present recent urban data innovation initiatives, especially CitySDK and OrganiCity, to underline the centrality of API design and governance for new kinds of civic and commercial services developed within and for cities. By bridging the fields of criticism, design, and implementation, we argue that City APIs as elements of infrastructures reveal how urban renewal processes become crucial sites of socio-political contestation between data science, technological development, urban management, and civic participation.

Re-engineering the City: Platform Ecosystems and the Capture of Urban Big Data

“…In a digitally mediated platform ecosystem, the key infrastructure that achieves this rule-based environment is the application programming interface (API). It is this rulebased operating infrastructure that enables ostensibly "open" forms of programmability to be achieved by digital platforms, while simultaneously ensuring the interactions these new platform innovations achieve also centralize or harvest any underlying data outputs (Helmond, 2015;Mackenzie, 2018;Raetzsch et al, 2019;Barns, 2020a). Facebook, as an iconic example, was able to morph its social media service into that of a platform ecosystem when it introduced the Facebook Developer Platform (FDP).…”

“…Despite posturing as platforms facilitating open exchange, co-creation, and value sharing, companies like YouTube and Facebook have long been recognized to deliberately enforce highly structured conditions of exchange that politicize their perceived neutrality (Gillespie, 2010). As access to data has become a critical input to wider data-driven value chains, owners of digital platforms-whether basic services like email, social media platforms, or ride-sharing platforms, or internet of things sensing platforms-have further extended their reach in ways that maximize the value of underlying data and accelerate the intelligence of the platform itself (Helmond, 2015;Raetzsch et al, 2019). Social media theorists understand the governing conditions of platform data through terms like "proprietary opacity" (Mackenzie, 2018), whereby the programmability of platforms, by virtue of their API, deliberately decentralize and extend conditions of data production while simultaneously recentralizing methods of data collection (Helmond, 2015).…”

The Evolution of Facebook's Graph Api

“…Lomborg and Bechmann, 2014), as elements of infrastructure (e.g. Raetzsch et al, 2019;, and the research politics of increasingly restricted APIs (e.g. Bruns, 2019).…”

The Development of Open Source Based Citizen Collaboration Applications for Infrastructure Management: My City Report

“…Therefore, our purpose is to develop a platform that all local governments can use in common and share as open source, and to examine its applicability. This article explains the construction status of "platformization" (Raetzsch et al, 2019), focusing on the management of city infrastructure via citizen collaboration and discussing the achievements and obstacles of the current system.…”