What Awaits Myanmar’s Uplands Farmers? Lessons Learned from Mainland Southeast Asia

Abstract

Mainland Southeast Asia (MSA) has seen sweeping upland land use changes in the past decades, with transition from primarily subsistence shifting cultivation to annual commodity cropping. This transition holds implications for local upland communities and ecosystems. Due to its particular political regime, Myanmar is at the tail of this development. However, with Myanmar’s official strategy of agricultural commercialization and intensification, recent liberalization of the national economy, and influx of multinational agricultural companies, the effects on upland land transitions could come fast. We analyze the current state of upland land use in Myanmar in a socio-economic and political context, identify the dynamics in three indicator commodity crops (maize, cassava, and rubber), and discuss the state driven economic, tenurial and policy reforms that have occurred in upland areas of mainland Southeast Asian countries in past decades. We draw on these insights to contextualize our study and hypothesize about possible transition pathways for Myanmar. The transition to annual commodity cropping is generally driven by a range of socio-economic and technical factors. We find that land use dynamics for the three indicator crops are associated with market demand and thus the opening of national Southeast-Asian economies, research and development of locally suitable high yielding varieties (HYVs), and subsidies for the promotion of seeds and inputs. In contrast, promotion of HYVs in marginal areas and without adequate agricultural extension services may results in agricultural contraction and yield dis-intensification. The environmental impacts of the transition depend on the transition pathway, e.g., through large-scale plantation projects or smallholder initiatives. The agricultural development in upland MSA follows a clear diffusion pattern with transition occurring first in Thailand, spreading to Vietnam, Cambodia and Laos. While these countries point to prospects for Myanmar, we hypothesize that changes will come slow due to Myanmar’s sparse rural infrastructure, with uncertainty about tenure, in particular in areas still troubled by armed conflicts, and unwillingness of international investors to approach Myanmar given the recent setbacks to the democratization process.

Domestic and export markets for Myanmar tiger grass brooms: A case study of Taunggya Village, Shan State

“…However, the recent rapid decline of swidden farming, which is being replaced with permanent farming (Heinimann et al 2017, Swe and Nawata 2020, Hashiguchi et al 2021 and the dramatic expansions of cropland (Chan and Takeda 2016, Zhang et al 2018, Jepsen et al 2019 in Myanmar may result in rapid habitat loss for tiger grass. It grows most dominantly in swidden fallows but colonizes only during the first few years before being replaced with woody species (Kushwaha et al 1981, Yokoyama 2004, Fukushima et al 2007).…”

Global Commodity Markets, Chinese Demand for Maize, and Deforestation in Northern Myanmar

“…Since then, commercial agriculture has spread throughout the country. Indeed, scholars are already exploring the effect of commodity crops, such as maize, cassava, and rubber, on other parts of countries in mainland Southeast Asian, and have proposed that Myanmar is at the tail end of this broad land transformation taking place across the region [39]. This paper combines remotely sensed data and field surveying to untangle the relationship between maize plantations and deforestation.…”

Agricultural commercialization in borderlands: Capturing the transformation of a tropical forest frontier through participatory mapping

“…Until recently, land use change research in Southeast Asia identified expansion of upland agricultural systems-such as shifting cultivation or swidden-as the leading cause of forest degradation and deforestation (Fox and Vogler, 2005;Kummer and Turner, 2007;Jepsen et al, 2019). Today, however, Southeast Asia's forest frontier is a key target region of increasing global demand for commercial crops, which have seen major expansion in plantation areas.…”