What Do Dental Students Think About Mandatory Laptop Programs?

Abstract

In spite of efforts by many dental schools to provide information technology resources for students, only a handful of studies have been conducted to determine what dental students think about these initiatives. There are no reports in the literature describing students' perceptions of mandatory laptop programs, which are now being implemented by at least 25 percent of North American dental schools. In schools that have implemented laptop programs, students are required either to enroll with their own laptops that meet specifications or to purchase a laptop from the school at matriculation. In some schools, students are also required to purchase curriculum support software that is bundled with the laptop. This study was conducted to determine students' opinions at U.S. dental schools with mandatory laptop programs about these aspects of this information technology initiative: frequency of use, perceived necessity of use, note-typing during lectures, effectiveness of training, influence on study habits, benefits, implementation problems, added value in relation to added tuition costs, impact on quality of dental education, overall rating of the laptop experience, and impact of the laptop on use of other electronic curriculum resources. Responses of students at schools that purchased packaged curriculum support software from a commercial vendor were compared with students' responses at schools where faculty provided their own educational software. Responses were also compared among freshmen, sophomores, and upperclassmen in a cross-sectional sample. In 2004, approximately 800 dental students at fourteen dental schools responded to eleven questions that requested their impressions and evaluation of mandatory laptop programs and associated educational software. These questions comprised one section of the IREC Students' Questionnaire (IREC=Institutional Readiness for Electronic Curriculum) that assessed students' perceptions of various aspects of information technology at their schools. The majority of students (63 percent) reported that the laptop and associated software were not essential for successful performance in their courses primarily because few instructors had modified their courses to take advantage of laptop capacities. Slightly more than half of the students reported their training was good or excellent, but felt that classroom-based "one size fits all" training was not effective. Less than 15 percent of the students reported that they had made substantial changes in their study habits as a consequence of the laptop program. The benefits perceived by students were primarily related to enhanced email communication with classmates and instructors and convenient access to the Internet and teachers' PowerPoint presentations. Implementation barriers included the inconvenience of carrying laptops to classes, lack of incentive to use the laptop and software because instructors did not require it, and poor quality software. Only 32 percent of students agreed that the value of the laptop and associated software ...

Attitudes towards e‐learning amongst dental students at the universities in Croatia

“…This is in line with our findings that previous experience with e‐learning courses positively influences attitude. However, experiences in the implementation of the e‐curriculum into North American dental schools show that <50% of students perceived an improvement of the educational quality . Freshmen, in comparison with upperclassmen, had a more positive attitude towards theirs mandatory laptop programmes in terms of educational value, usage frequency and cost‐effectiveness .…”

Dentistry students’ perceptions of learning management systems

“…In addition, conservative teaching habits, lack of provision of professional development in ICT modalities and insufficient time allocated to resource development and maintenance contribute to a low take‐up (27, 28). Conflictive attitudes towards eLearning have also been detected amongst a number of dental students (29). The study also aimed at exploring the nature of these attitudes within Faculty student cohort.…”

Computer Use Among Post Graduate Dental Students in India

“…The use of laptop is more common among Indian post graduates due to the portability. Few US dental schools have introduced mandatory laptop programs where laptops are provided to students with all required software at a cheaper rate (17). Such initiative may be highly successful in India looking at the number of dental students who are opting for laptops.…”