What Do Observational Datasets Say about Modeled Tropospheric Temperature Trends since 1979?

Abstract

Updated tropical lower tropospheric temperature datasets covering the period 1979-2009 are presented and assessed for accuracy based upon recent publications and several analyses conducted here. We conclude that the lower tropospheric temperature (T LT ) trend over these 31 years is +0.09 ± 0.03 °C decade −1 . Given that the surface temperature (T sfc ) trends from three different groups agree extremely closely among themselves (~ +0.12 °C decade −1 ) this indicates that the -scaling ratio‖ (SR, or ratio of atmospheric trend to surface trend: T LT /T sfc ) of the observations is ~0.8 ± 0.3. This is significantly different from the average SR calculated from the IPCC AR4 model simulations which is ~1.4. This result indicates the majority of AR4 simulations tend to portray significantly greater warming in the troposphere relative to the surface than is found in observations. The SR, as an internal, normalized metric of model behavior, largely avoids the confounding influence of short-term fluctuations such as El Niños which make direct comparison of trend magnitudes less confident, even over multi-decadal periods. OPEN ACCESSRemote Sensing 2010, 2 2149

Atmospheric changes through 2012 as shown by iteratively homogenized radiosonde temperature and wind data (IUKv2)

“…These data have been interpreted as indicating too little warming trend in the upper compared to the lower troposphere (Fu et al 2011, Po-Chedley andFu 2012) and one satellite product shows less warming in the atmosphere than at the surface (Christy et al 2010). Caution is warranted however because the satellites suffer from uncertain changes over time in calibration and other inhomogeneities, exacerbated by the manipulations of the data necessary to extract the signals of concern here (CCSP 2006).…”

Assessing the value of Microwave Sounding Unit–radiosonde comparisons in ascertaining errors in climate data records of tropospheric temperatures

“…compared MSU measurements with the results from a subset of a single radiosonde data set and concluded that the University of Alabama, Huntsville (UAH) satellite data set was more accurate than the RSS data. They focused on trends in the data set differences over 5‐year and 10 year periods, and on a limited analysis period Christy et al [2010] Christy et al [2007]…”

Prospects of Tools from Differential Games in the Study of Macroeconomics of Climate Change

“…Unfortunately, however, there are also studies that question the accuracy or even conclusions of this report, see e.g. [20], [65], [37]. As a scientist, and lay-man in this field, the overall impression is that we start of to see some global contours and factors impacting each other, but that an in-depth understanding of the material is far from complete.…”