Who opposes labor regulation? Explaining variation in employers’ opinions

Abstract

Competing accounts of the effect of globalization on labor politics agree that firms influence regulations, but make contrasting predictions for which firms are most likely to oppose regulations. Using survey data from employers in 19,000 manufacturing firms in 82 developing countries, we examine the determinants of employers' opinions towards labor regulation. In contrast to the predictions of optimistic theories of globalization, we find that (1) firms that export are more likely to have negative opinions towards labor regulation than those that sell domestically, and (2) firms that receive foreign direct investment have similar views as firms that rely only on domestic capital. Further, we show that systematic differences in employers' opinions depend on the intensity of the competitive pressures they face and their use of skilled workers. In doing so, we provide an empirically grounded account of the heterogeneous opinions of key actors in economic policy-making in developing countries.

Aging in Latin America and the Caribbean: Social protection and quality of life of older persons

“…Enforcement can be particularly effective for large firms that employ informal workers (Bosch et al, 2020). However, attempting harsher punishments for informal employment may result in more formal employment but could also lead to higher unemployment (Almeida and Carneiro, 2012;Amengual, Coslovsky, and Yang, 2017;Kanbur and Ronconi, 2016). To minimize this downside, countries can combine enhanced oversight with other pro-formalization measures.…”

Who demands labour (de)regulation in the developing world?: Insider–outsider theory revisited

“…The framing does not allow for the possibility that some business owners consider labour regulations as a contributor to the productivity of their business. This possibility is not inconceivable; as shown byAmengual et al (2017), almost half of employers choose the first option (i.e. that labour regulations are not an obstacle for their establishment), and a relatively small portion of employers describes labour regulations as a 'major' (10 per cent) or 'very severe' (5 per cent) obstacle.…”