Who to find to endorse? Evaluation of online influencers among young consumers and its implications for effective influencer marketing

Abstract

Purpose This study aims to identify the dimensions used by young consumers to evaluate effective online influencers; determine the impact of demographic segmentation – that is, gender, behavioral segmentation and whether young consumers often follow the advice of online influencers to make a purchase – on the evaluative dimensions. The results will inform advertisers regarding the types of online influencers that they should feature to endorse their products to create desirable promotion effects. Design/methodology/approach This study adopted a multistage method. This study first conducted eight focus groups with 48 participants between 18 and 24 years of age to explore their evaluation of online influencers. This study then conducted a survey with a questionnaire developed from the focus group results. This study used convenience sampling and administered the questionnaire to 475 participants (mean age, 19.5 years). Findings The results of factor analysis revealed seven dimensions used by young consumers to evaluate online influencers. The most salient dimensions were credibility, appearance and content production techniques. The results of t-testing also show that gender and behavioral segmentation variables had an impact on these evaluative dimensions in the four tested product categories. Practical implications This study provides advertisers with a set of criteria to select appropriate online influencers in various advertising settings, such as the promotion of gender-specific products, and in various product categories that target young consumer markets. Originality/value To the best of the authors’ knowledge, this is the first study to examine the dimensions used by young consumers to evaluative online influencers in relation to product endorsement.

Examining purchase intention for luxury fashion: integrating theory of reasoned action, with affect-behavior-cognition (ABC) model, identity and social identity theories

“…Attitude toward celebrity endorsement has a positive impact on brand attractiveness and the findings are consistent with Aw and Labrecque (2020). As young consumers are highly influenced by KoLs or celebrities, their engagement in marketing campaigns would in turn capture the attention of consumers toward the brand (Tsen and Cheng, 2021). When the KoLs' or celebrities' endorsements become widely used and commercialized, their choice of the KoL or celebrity would affect the credibility and trustworthiness of the endorsements which are highly dependent on the KoL's or celebrity's public image and behavior.…”

Organic food and Instagram health and wellbeing influencers: an emerging country's perspective with gender as a moderator

“…For example, firm reputation is an important aspect for cultures outside of North America (Jin et al, 2008) and should be examined by future studies in forming brand attitude. Other variable that can be considered are influencer's political sense, authenticity (Tsen and Cheng, 2021), and homophily, the similarity between the consumers and influencer attributes such as gender, age, education, interests, lifestyle, etc (Li and Peng, 2021). A cross-cultural study comparing attitude towards influencers in emerging vis-a-vis developed markets could further enrich the phenomenon of influencer marketing (Trivedi and Sama, 2020).…”

“…Thus, one of the major challenges with influencer marketing is identifying a suitable influencer who can effectively reach the brand's target consumers through social media channels (Araujo et al, 2016). Determining the criteria used by the brand's target audience to identify online influencers is a difficult but fundamental issue for e-marketers (Tsen and Cheng, 2021).…”

Be constantly different! How to manage influencer authenticity

“…An influencer's credibility is likely to be damaged when his/her selling intent is disclosed by a company (Colliander & Erlandsson, 2015). Hence, the extent to which an influencer genuinely shares his true thoughts, personal views, and feelings is another important criterion, which is typically included in the concept of 'influencer authenticity' (Tsen & Cheng, 2021). Being authentic makes it easier for consumers to identify with the influencer as consumers think that they share similar interests and values (Kelman, 2006).…”