“Why couldn’t we do this more often?”: exploring the feasibility of virtual and distributed work in product design engineering

Abstract

Lower costs and higher employee satisfaction are some of the benefits driving organizations to adopt dispersed and virtual working arrangements. Despite these advantages, product design engineering teams—those who develop physical products—have not widely adopted this working style due to perceived critical dependence on physical facilities and the belief that it is ineffective to communicate technical details virtually. This paper uses the mass shift in working conditions caused by the COVID-19 pandemic to explore the feasibility of virtual and distributed work in product design engineering. We conducted 20 semi-structured interviews with product design engineers working virtually to uncover current challenges of, and the beginning of promising strategies for, effective virtual engineering work. We categorize and analyze Tangible Design activities, Intangible Design activities, and Communication and Project Management activities throughout the product design process. Contrary to present opinions, we found that much of a product design engineer's work is realizable in a virtual and distributed setting. However, there are still many challenges, especially when attempting Tangible Design activities—those that require physical products and tools—from home. These challenges, missing from existing virtual product design engineering literature, include but are not limited to individuals’ lessened sense of accountability, fewer de-risking opportunities before product sign-off, and limited supervision of production staff. Product design engineers described novel strategies that emerged organically to mitigate these challenges, such as creating digital alternatives for engineering reviews and sign-offs and leveraging rapid prototyping. Recent advances in technology, an increased commitment to reducing environmental impact, and better work-life balance expectations from new generations of workers will only push society faster towards a distributed working model. Thus, it is critical that we use this opportunity to understand the existing challenges for distributed product design engineers, so that organizations can best prepare and become resilient to future shocks.

Team and communication impacts of remote work for complex aerospace system development

“…Now, I have to set up a meeting…what might be a 5 min conversation turns into a 30‐min conversation, potentially cause I don't go to their desk. Now, I have to book a time with them .” This challenge was also noted in studies of physical product designers, where iteration is also common in the design process 42,45 …”

“…Much of this communication between tightly coupled teams used to happen informally, such as at the edge of meetings, in the hallways, or in the lunchroom, often referred to as 'watercooler' conversations. 42 Informal communication is spontaneous, unplanned, and is described as chance conversations that arise typically from co-location in the same space. Informal communication can also be intentional, like visiting someone's desk for a quick question.…”

Creativity in virtual teams: Systematic review, synthesis and research agenda

“…Thus, the level of social connectedness between team members will ultimately determine how the creative collaboration unfolds. Whereas high tendencies for social loafing (Monzani et al, 2014) and low sense of individual accountability (Ferguson et al, 2022) become more serious concerns in such settings, stronger social connections between members provide the needed transparency and goal clarity to alleviate some of these negative implications (Kristensson & Norlander, 2003; Roy et al, 1996).…”

Circle Back Next Week: The Effect of Meeting-Free Weeks on Distributed Workers’ Unstructured Time and Attention Negotiation

“…For decades, Human-Computer Interaction (HCI) researchers have studied distributed teams, identifying current challenges [14,48,86], and designing technical solutions to overcome them [64,79,97]. One well-documented challenge in distributed collaboration is a loss of awareness of colleagues' work [4,31]. It is well documented that in response, distributed teams add more meetings [4,31,96].…”