Why information technology is constrained in tackling tax noncompliance in developing countries

Abstract

Purpose This study aims to investigate the reasons for the large scale tax noncompliance prevalent in underdeveloped countries despite many years of information technology (IT)-led tax administration reforms. Design/methodology/approach The study is based on in-depth interviews with 18 senior tax administration officials. Their experiences were used to construct a grounded theory to explain the constraint of IT in tackling the prevalent tax noncompliance in underdeveloped countries. Findings First, IT is not immune to the systemic corruption prevalent in many developing countries; hence, it is quickly compromised. Second, IT can be efficient in dealing with registered taxpayers but cannot deal with the overwhelming large numbers of operators in the informal sector. Third, E-tax administration, which is a hallmark of IT-led tax administrations in advanced countries, is very slow to catch up in developing countries. A computerized tax administration alone, as currently obtainable in developing countries, is not enough to engender large usage of e-filing. Businesses, especially small and medium-sized enterprises (SMEs), need IT infrastructure as well to align with tax administration. Unfortunately, basic IT infrastructure is yet to be available to a large section of SMEs in developing countries. Research limitations/implications Underdeveloped countries are diverse. This study is from a single country and there may be need to take note of other countries’ peculiarities. However, Nigeria constitutes a good case study. Practical implications There is need to reform the people and systems along with IT originality/value. Originality/value To the authors’ knowledge, this study is the first to explore this very important question and among the first to explore tax administrators’ perspectives.

Do public governance and patriotism matter? Sales tax compliance among small and medium enterprises in developing countries: Jordanian evidence

“…Most developing nations require revenues to develop and maintain their public infrastructure, education, health services and other public services, and, to this end, they require increased efforts when it comes to collecting taxes. This is particularly true as tax revenue is a key component of the gross domestic product (GDP) and, as such, nations need to develop more effective means of collection (Umar and Masud, 2020;Bird et al, 2008). Thus, governments depend on tax revenues to cover their social and fiscal activities (Alshira'h and Abdul-Jabbar, 2020;Lois et al, 2019).…”

A study on listed companies' compliance with value-added tax: the evolving role of compliance officer in Oman

“…The impact of intergovernmental shifts on firms’ corporate tax non-compliance was investigated by Ye and Xiang (2020). The rationales about large-scale tax non-compliance in underdeveloped nations’ tax administration reforms were studied by Umar and Masud (2020). The factors of compliance disclosure on of IFRS among listed insurance companies were examined by Suleiman and Sani (2021).…”

Observational Study of Tax Compliance and Tax Evasion in Nigeria

“…In this regard, various factors are responsible for online provision of goods and services ranging from efficient international logistics, communication network, country-to-country collaboration, the opening up of some conservative economies as well as a secure international payment system (Umar & Masud, 2019). Consequentially, it follows that with the increase in activity on the technological platform, governments across the globe are coming up with fiscal measures to ensure that businesses pay their fair share of taxes in the country in which they operate (Umar & Masud, 2019). Nevertheless, these fiscal measures have to be designed in a manner which enables the government to raise revenue while at the same time, establish an appropriate environment conducive to the flourishing of the e-commerce sector.…”

“…In broad terms, a digital economy relies heavily on information technology while conducting trade through the internet in a manner as if the goods sold on traditional shopping centres shelves and services rendered by individuals or corporates, have now been shifted to virtual shelves found on the World Wide Web. Indeed, the growth of the ecommerce sector is evidenced by the E-commerce Statistics (2020) which provides that e-retail sales accounted for 14.1% of all retail sales worldwide and these figures are expected to arrive at 22% in 2023 (Umar & Masud, 2019).…”

“…Some of these countries have been classified as fragile states because of inadequate tax revenue (OECD, 2014a). The problem of low tax revenue generation in developing countries has been a global concern for many decades (Umar & Masud, 2019).…”