Wind Farm Siting and Protected Areas in Catalonia: Planning Alternatives or Reproducing 'One-Dimensional Thinking'?

Abstract

Abstract:Wind energy is an emblem of sustainability with the potential to promote a qualitative alternative to current energy systems and nuclear options for CO 2 reduction. However, wind farm siting often conflicts with aspirations to conserve traditional landscapes and wildlife habitats. In this paper we adopt a Critical Theory perspective, informed by Herbert Marcuse`s work, to study the discourse concerning wind energy siting in Catalonia, Spain. We give particular attention to how tensions between potentially conflicting sustainability objectives are addressed and by whom. Based on a review of this siting discourse and the application of Marcuse's theory, we find that the Catalan wind energy siting discourse is both influenced by and reproducing what Marcuse referred to as the 'one-dimensional thinking' of technology as ideology: erasing the possibility of critical dialectical thought by subsuming the question of "what should be" under the question of "what is". This has implications both for how these conflicts are investigated and for the sustainability of decisions taken. We conclude that closer attention to the role of 'one-dimensional thinking' in wind energy siting discourses could improve not only the understanding of their logic but might also have the potential to help make them more democratic.

A Field Method for Landscape Conservation Surveying: The Landscape Assessment Protocol (LAP)

“…Furthermore, LAP could support policy-relevant advocacy for practical conservation, promoting the active involvement and voicing of participant perspectives, as underlined by conservation policy frameworks [8,16] and landscape literacy initiatives [13]. LAP can be important for rapidly evaluating conservation conditions in sensitive situations such as protected areas [77] and perhaps integrating this data within assessment of cultural ecosystem services [15,[78][79][80] and other approaches where participatory science is called for (e.g., [81]).…”

Energy Efficiency as a Wicked Problem

“…City planning as a wicked problem was discussed by Engberg [30] and Yearworth [31] and also partly by Pere and Farrell [32]. Pere and Farrell [32] reviewed the wind energy siting debate in the Catalonia region in Spain over the past 30 years. They argued that wind energy siting can be viewed as a wicked problem.…”

Crafting electricity through social protest: Afro-descendant and indigenous Embera communities protesting for hydroelectric infrastructure in Utría National Park, Colombia

“…The desire to have access to electricity, railways, roads, pumped water, and modern communications is bound up with a particular idea of what a modern society ought to have (Larkin, 2013). For political philosopher Herbert Marcuse (1955, 1964), that idea is a basic feature of late-industrial society, inculcated with a technological rationality, where discourses, thoughts, needs, and feelings are judged through reference to a technologically constructed experience of reality (Ariza-Montobbio and Farrell, 2012; Farrell, 2011). Infrastructure is a central part of what makes that experience possible and desirable—be it the functioning of a mobile phone, a television, an automobile, a computer or a refrigerator—becoming a basic requirement for achieving what is considered the good life (Marcuse, 1964).…”