Wunderlich syndrome is an uncommon condition of spontaneous subcapsular and perirenal hemorrhage of atraumatic etiology in the kidney, with the potential to spread to the retroperitoneal region beyond the perirenal fascias. Its clinical manifestations usually include Lenk's triad, namely, acute flank pain, flank mass, and hemodynamic instability, which vary depending on the causative underlying renal pathology. Tumor bleeding of benign and malignant renal neoplasms is the most common cause of this syndrome, followed by vascular disorders and renal cystic diseases. Here, we report the case of a unilateral subcapsular renal hematoma on account of a left atrophic kidney with parapelvic cystic formations and variant hypoplastic vasculature which was successfully managed via radical nephrectomy after initial conservative treatment. Spontaneous cystic rupture contributed to the emergence of the syndrome, and its mechanisms are being addressed.