Yoga From the Mat Up: How words alight on bodies

Abstract

Yoga is a unique form of expert movement that promotes an increasingly subtle interpenetration of thought and movement. The mindful nature of its practice, even at expert levels, challenges the idea that thought and mind are inevitably disruptive to absorbed coping. Building on parallel phenomenological and ethnographic studies of skilful performance and embodied apprenticeship, we argue for the importance in yoga of mental access to embodied movement during skill execution by way of a case study of instruction and practice in two related traditions, Iyengar and Anusara. Sharing a pose repertoire, they are based on distinctive philosophical systems with different teaching styles and metaphoric structures. To address relations between pedagogy and practice in embodied expertise, and to investigate the reciprocal influences of embodiment and thought, we explore in detail the linguistically mediated learning context where practitioners work with yoga teachers. Here, the mind/body problem comes to practical life. We demonstrate the effects of words on bodies, as knowledge is literally incorporated. We show why interpersonal influence on our movement capacities is sometimes needed to enhance expertise. We theorize and identify 'signature patterns of tension' among practitioners. These patterns have four sources: ghost gestures, innate differences in bodily form, functional fusing, and signature patterns of affective experience, modulation and expression. These patterns of tension produce 'silent zones', cognitively impenetrable actions, functional fusing of a skilful, compensatory form, and signature patterns of pain and damage. We show how instruction can disrupt these silent zones, enhancing mental and physical flexibility.

The performative pleasure of imprecision: a diachronic study of entrainment in music performance

“…Sutton was privy to the entire coding and analysis process and provided valuable feedback and guidance throughout the project. As with other research that has taken as its focus the contents of subjects’ experience and used semi-structured interviews in its methodology (e.g., Downey, 2002 , 2005 , 2010 on capoeira and McIlwain and Sutton, 2014a on yoga), there is an inevitable discrepancy between that which a subject experiences and a subject’s report of that which he or she experiences. While data obtained from semi-structured interviews were analyzed in light of the field notes Geeves (2012) made while observing each musician perform, we are making inferences about the experience of performance from reports of this experience.…”

The Lotus in the Mud: A Conceptual Model of Livestream Yoga Service Experience

“…As such, yoga teaching benefits from good pedagogical practices informed by education literature (e.g., Bourne 2010 ). Yet, pedagogical education frameworks for yoga teaching via different modalities (e.g., face-to-face, online or blended) are lacking (e.g., Antony 2016 ; McIIwain and Sutton 2014 ).…”

Breadth and Depth of Knowledge in Expert Versus Novice Athletes

“…Talk about embodied skills can be analogical and indirect, with groups of experts often evolving local responses to the challenges of languaging experience, often "beyond the easy flow of everyday speech" (Sheets-Johnstone, 2009, p. 336). Ethnographic work in these fields often takes the form of participant involvement, as the researcher becomes enculturated into a cultural and physical setting which transforms their bodies, perceptual-cognitive systems, and understanding of the world: examples include work on boxing (Wacquant, 2003), capoeira (Downey, 2005), martial arts (Samudra, 2008), mountain bike racing (Bicknell, 2010) and yoga (McIlwain & Sutton, 2014). Sports psychologists could potentially benefit from attempting the kind of longer-term immersion in the specific culture of expert practitioners at which anthropologists have excelled.…”